As I was composing this post in my head, I realized how lucky I’ve been. I had a complication free pregnancy, the birth I wanted, and so far relatively few instances of illness. We go to the doctor for shots, and that’s it. I like it that way. His pediatrician brought up his lack of speech back at 12 months, but after a hearing test she was satisfied and didn’t say anything until his last appointment. Right before we left for Europe she recommended us to a speech therapy program and let us know it would be a good idea to get him tested.
Today, four very nice women came over (one program coordinator, one speech therapist, one developmental therapist (is that the right term?) and one woman doing some shadowing) and spent about 2 hours with us, playing with T1, listening to me interacting with him, and asking me an astounding number of questions. Questions about things I’ve never even considered!
After about an hour together the therapists felt ready to present their findings. The speech therapist said he’s doing great at some things, like linking together multiple consonants and vowels, but overall he’s very behind, testing at about 9-12 months (he is 18 months now). He still doesn’t use any words unprompted. The develpomental therapist placed him at somewhere just about 12 months for his cognitive abilities, worrying that he doesn’t respond to commands like “give me the cup” and doesn’t identify pictures (even things like shoes, a thing/word he loves, and that he will babble on about and fetch when we go say the words go bye-bye or ask him about his shoes). I’m sure there are other reasons that I’m forgetting because I don’t have a summary in front of me, but that was the general message. They want him to have two hours of therapy per week, one hour with a speech therapist and one hour working on his cognitive abilities. Therapy would happen at home, which is great now, but will feel absolutely essential in the winter when bundling him up and finding parking would be a nightmare.
I’m doing fine emotionally. I mean, I knew he wasn’t talking so they didn’t really give me any new information, you know? They came to my house to verify some things I suspected, and are willing to be the resource I need to fix a problem we have (lots of temper tantrums, most dealing with his inability to communicate his needs). Because I thought some of you would be curious, I made this little iphone video while he was in the bath today. This is typically a time when he is very vocal (I think he likes the acoustics) and this is a good example of what he sounds like when he is babbling a lot.
We do sign with him, and he is great at a sign for milk, and waving his hand to let you know he wants to go bye-bye, but so far I can’t get him to use “more” unprompted, or acknowledge the sign I made up for “num-nums” in an effort to get him to let me know if he wants to eat.
The evaluation itself was free, but the program will cost us something, we’re just not sure how much yet. Our tax return information puts us at $30/month directly to the program, which we can handle, but figuring out what the insurance company will bill us for (it’s UofC student health insurance, and after our hearing test they said over the phone that they do not reimburse for “developmental delays”). I’m going to have to work on figuring out what it’s going to cost because that will determine whether we decide to do the therapy. If we consider the cost to be exorbitant, we are considering putting this off until next year when we are back on the Company X insurance plan. If there are professional therapists that specialize in this area who would like to weigh in I’d love to hear how horrible this idea is. (Ha!)
You know what? I lied about feeling fine. I am wracked with mommy guilt. At the end of the meeting I told the women I was very happy with how the meeting went, but that I couldn’t shake the feeling that we are parents are to blame for this, and that maybe if we made some small and simple changes we could fix this on our own. They assured me that after spending some time in our home they didn’t think that was the case at all, and that we could try putting this off for three months and implementing some different training techniques, but I could tell the speech therapist in particular thought this was a bad idea. I just can’t stop thinking that if I just tried harder to never be on the computer when he is awake, or if I would follow him around and talk to him incessantly labeling things when we go to the park, or talk to him in a sing-song voice every moment during dinner that therapy wouldn’t be necessary. Then I think he’s just too far gone and I need to just accept I ruined him. Then I think about having the next one and I realize that it’s not going to be possible to do give T2 the attention I irrationally think T1 must have needed to avoid delays. Then I just feel guilty all over again.
In summary T1 is probably going to start therapy and I am feeling like I might need some therapy of my own to swim out of this sea of guilt I’m drowning myself in.
October 10th, 2011 on 9:20 pm
Every child is different, every set of parents is different. You’re doing a great job, so don’t feel badly! You’re doing the right thing seeking help, and you’ll come to an answer you feel comfortable with. Even if the program is too expensive, you might be able to work with students or something else less expensive rather than just putting it off.
Reply
October 10th, 2011 on 9:26 pm
Im sure it doesnt mean much coming from a non-mom, but try not to feel guilty! All children develop at different rates. Just because he isn’t where he “should” be now doesn’t me you ruined him! Boys especially can be slower with these things but then I’m sure once he does reach the place you’d like him to be he just won’t stop! Good luck to all of you!
Reply
October 10th, 2011 on 9:28 pm
Ugh. Yes. No advice whatsoever, just sympathy. Today my 21 month old daughters had their follow-up weight check since they’d fallen so far off the growth curve at their last appointment. They gained almost nothing (one and four ounces) and we have to go back in four more weeks. There are concerns about failure to thrive, endocrine issues, etc. I’m flipping out and stressing and there’s (seemingly) nothing I can do. Guilt up to my eyebrows. I’m drowning in it.
Ready for how small? 21 months and both are barely over 19lbs (that’s not even a weight percentile!). Ugh again.
Reply
October 10th, 2011 on 9:29 pm
Don’t beat yourself up, T1 is so very lucky that you are able to stay home with him. You will figure out what will work best for you both emotional and with the money situation. You could also look into programs that do a delay pay type of payment. I know that where I work they do something similar and that could help ease the burden until you are back to having more of a $$$ income.
I think it’s wonderful that you make the arrangements to have T1 even looked at, so many parents wait and wait. Be strong you are a wonderful parent!
Reply
October 10th, 2011 on 9:29 pm
Frankly, there’s no way I would delay therapy for my child in this situation.
Reply
Megan Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 11:10 am
I agree. I worry if you do, that T1 will be even further behind when you start and have trouble catching up before he starts school. I tend to think the sooner the better.
But, don’t let the guilt overwhelm you. This does not mean you are a bad mother. T1 will catch up!
Reply
October 10th, 2011 on 9:30 pm
I was just thinking about something I’ve heard in the past. I’ve heard that if two parents speak two different languages to a child, initial speech development could be delayed. But once the child catches on, they take off like the wind. I know your husband is Polish, so I thought this might apply in your case.
Regardless, it is clear that you and your husband provide an awesome environment for your child. Try not to feel bad. And like so many decisions that you have to make for your son, do what you feel is right.
Reply
shannon Reply:
October 10th, 2011 at 10:32 pm
Yes! I was going to say the same thing regarding the two languages spoken in the home. I’ve heard the same thing, and I’ve seen it to be true with family and friends that I know who have raised their children to be bilingual. On a more personal level, my middle child experienced speech delay and was diagnosed at the same age as T1 (18 months). We started speech therapy and it helped a lot. We went through our local school district’s early intervention program and so the rate was according to our income and very reasonable. He’s now 4 and is almost all the way caught up to his peers. Because this is such a crucial time for language development, I wouldn’t put it off, do whatever it takes to fund it. And don’t feel guilty. You are a dedicated and loving mother. Be confident in your parenting choices, and be confident going forward. Good luck!
Reply
Tiffany Reply:
October 10th, 2011 at 10:57 pm
I second the idea of going through the school district. Good Luck with whatever you decide.
Reply
kathy Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 8:30 am
i was going to say the same thing! my cousin did not speak till she was four because she was so confused. her parents were using English and Spanish interchangeably. i have heard that it makes it easier for the child to separate it in their brain if one parent speaks one language all the time and the other speaks the other language all the time. not sure what you would do when talking to each other.
Reply
Rachel Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 10:45 am
I grew up hearing three languages and I started speaking pretty early. Same with many of my mixed-nationality friends. I also live in a country where everyone has to be bilingual and most are trilingual. Perhaps we’ve been bred to soak up language.
Not to worry you or anything, just pointing out that many languages don’t necessarily cause late speech development.
I wish you luck!
Reply
allison Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 11:24 am
Here is a fact sheet on what to expect when your child is learning more than one language: http://www.asha.org/public/speech/development/BilingualChildren.htm#expectations
Reply
Erin Reply:
October 12th, 2011 at 11:02 am
This is all true - children growing up hearing multiple languages have a substantial delay, and then catch up (I think around 7 or 8). In the end, kids growing up learning two languages DO get to the same level as their peers, are better at math, AND know two languages!
Reply
October 10th, 2011 on 9:31 pm
Do not feel guilty! Norms are just averages, and lots of kids find their groove later and turn out fine, everyone knows tons of late talkers, especially boys. If TH speaks Polish to him, that can also contribute initially to speech delays, I believe, but obviously he will overcome them and be bilingual and more adept at learning other languages as he grows. I watched your sweet video and there’s nothing about T1 that screamed “get help NOW!” You will move forward with what you know, do the best you can and reevaluate as things become clearer, which they will as he gets older.
Reply
October 10th, 2011 on 9:32 pm
Your second-to-last paragraph makes me so sad! You didn’t ruin him. My niece had my sister-in-law smother her with communication at all times and it really took until two for her to talk. My sister-in-law is a teacher and she and her husband are Ivy League grads with degrees in education and they had to learn there are just things they couldn’t control even though they wanted to. So what I’m saying is that sometimes kids will take more time than others but it doesn’t mean there’s a lasting, permanent problem that’s going to mean something really bad for his future. You know? My niece is 7 and bright, articulate, intelligent - definitely caught up. Don’t be so hard on yourself! Focus on how fantastic it is that you’ve been so proactive with this.
Reply
Jenna Reply:
October 10th, 2011 at 10:37 pm
Thanks C. This comment was helpful.
Reply
CD Reply:
October 10th, 2011 at 10:43 pm
My niece also took a long time to walk because SIL and hubby are vegetarians and the little one wasn’t getting enough protein! They actually did take her to some type of motor skills therapist pretty early and in that arena too, she’s caught up with her peers.
Reply
October 10th, 2011 on 9:34 pm
Oh sweet friend, please try and take a breath and not blame yourself too much. I doubt that there is a mama on this planet that hasn’t been convinced at some point that they ruined their child- myself included. My son is driving now (ouch!), but when he was T1′s age he was barely speaking. I would get a word every once and a while, but mostly pointing and grunting. My best friend at the time had a son the exact same age and he was speaking in complete sentences. I was devastated!
To make a long story short Michael began speaking when he was ready to (and when I took an active part in making it difficult for him not to). I picked a couple of words each week to really focus on (cup, milk, etc) and then every chance I got I worked with him. He had to at least make an effort before I would give him what he wanted. When he tried, he got LOTS of praise.
Maybe it’s something, maybe it’s nothing. Either way, he’s lucky to have parents that have his back.
As his mama you’ll make the right decision for both he and you. Trust yourself to know what’s best here and know that we’ll be here to support you either way.
As for my son? He’s a freshman in high school working on college level studies. I can’t get him to shut up.
Reply
October 10th, 2011 on 9:43 pm
You’re such an academic that I feel like this will ultimately be a positive experience for you all. You will learn so much and I know you’ve probably already started the research on these topics (multiple languages, signing, language development, etc). An expert in child-development at your fingertips for a few weeks? How awesome. Rationally, I know you know there’s a ton to learn, and P is lucky to have parents who can help him in life, with multilingualism or sleep training or discovering God. You (or anyone) can’t be expected to be an expert in all these areas without some external help.
Your humility in sharing your challenges so openly is what makes this space a place we all keep coming back to. Thanks for your honesty.
Reply
October 10th, 2011 on 9:44 pm
Oh hone. We’ll pray for you and your family!
Reply
October 10th, 2011 on 9:47 pm
There is nothing to feel guilty about! Some children just need a little extra help, that’s all. It’s not your fault, you didn’t do anything wrong. Early invention can be so helpful (the cost is WORTH IT!) - in a few years no one will even know there was an issue! You certainly did not “ruin” your son.
Reply
October 10th, 2011 on 9:52 pm
I’m really sorry for this “bump” in the road. I’m sure it’s rough, but you seem like great parents and I’m sure there’s nothing you could have done differently. I hope everything works itself out and T1 starts speaking when he’s ready.
Reply
October 10th, 2011 on 9:54 pm
Mama guilt is the worst - but you haven’t ruined your son. I definitely wouldn’t put off therapy if you can help it. It might be expensive but I wouldn’t want to wait another year and let him get further behind in that time.
My sister has a daughter with several learning disabilities (sensory processing, auditory processing, dyslexia - to name a few) and she might have some resources for you. Her daughter had some delays when she was younger too. She still has her issues especially in academics but has overcome quite a bit.
If I remember right, you can take T1 to get evaluated by someone in Chicago Public Schools and they’ll probably say what the women who came today said - but I swear the state provided resources for my niece. She had an occupational therapist, speech pathologist, etc. come to their house weekly when she was a baby - probably around 15 months or so. I think the page I’m linking below has some decent info on it.
http://illinoisearlylearning.org/faqs/special-needs.htm
Good luck! If you need any extra help - shoot me an email. I also have a cousin in the area who is a speech pathologist who may be able to help you guys.
Reply
crystal Reply:
October 10th, 2011 at 9:57 pm
See if you can it through the schools. In Iowa they do free speech therapy if you go through the schools!
Reply
Chantal Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 1:05 pm
Yes, try going through the school district. In Wisconsin, it is free too. My 4 year old needs to be evaluated because she is hard to understand. I, myself, had speech therapy as a child from age 4 through third grade because no one could understand anything that I said. Cognitively, it means nothing! I ended up valedictorian of my class. Do not beat yourself up over this!
Reply
October 10th, 2011 on 9:54 pm
I completely understand how you feel, but I think that it’s less of you being at fault and more just that you care/love him so much. I know each child is different, but R’s cousin has similar (but worse) problems, and her speech and cognitive therapists have helped so much, it’s crazy to see. They’ve helped not only with the tangible differences, but also to cut down on the frustration across the board for the whole family. And the thing is, they’re a family of three, with the first two kids being completely developmentally on track, some of the most amazing parents I’ve ever seen, etc. I would definitely say that if you and TH can spring it any way, invest in that therapy sooner rather than later. I think it will pay off for P in so many ways, and you two by extension.
Reply
October 10th, 2011 on 10:01 pm
Oh Jenna, big hugs to you. First, ignore all the haters. There will always be haters who will crawl out of the woodwork at this kind of post and point out everything you COULD have done differently. Don’t let it get to you. You are an awesome mother and T1 is so lucky to have you as his mama. The fact that you are even worrying shows you’re a good mama. There are plenty of “smart, normal, brilliant, successful, etc.” people who had some kind of a delay as a kid. In fact..Einstein had a speech delay and we all know how that worked out for him.
The important thing is to take the information you have been given and get your son the help he needs. Do you have to do every.single.little.thing the “experts” tell you to? No. Do what you can afford and what you’re comfortable with. If you see he’s improving, great. If not, gradually add more therapy in. Don’t stress yourself out over this. T1 isn’t broken. He isn’t damaged. He’s T1. He’s perfect and special and sweet and your little boy. You will all learn to meet his needs in a way that helps him thrive. Best of luck to you. Go hug your little boy and remember that God made him exactly the way he his.
Reply
October 10th, 2011 on 10:02 pm
Oh Jenna - I am so sorry you are going through this. But no way - NO WAY - did you “ruin him.” He is a happy, loved little boy. You will figure out the rest.
Reply
October 10th, 2011 on 10:05 pm
I want to say, “Don’t beat yourself up, Jenna! You’re doing fantastic and can’t blame yourself,” but I know it probably won’t help. It’s TRUE though. But, from my experience with Eli and his eating issues, I know that regardless what people (both friends and professionals told me), I still beat myself up about what we should/could have done differently. I am constantly thinking about how I will do things differently with our next one, too. But, the truth of the matter is, when it really comes down to it there likely really is nothing you could have done differently because you didn’t know that he needed help, if that makes sense.
For example, looking back, there are lots of things I could have done with Eli from the start of introducing foods that would have completely changed the way the last two years have gone for us in terms of eating. But, at the time I had no idea that the little quirks or things he was doing or not doing were problems! So many 12 month olds don’t say a single word, so why would you think to go overboard on speech practice to help, you know?
My point is, you don’t know about these things until you know, and then you go from there to do what you can to help. We’ve worked with both speech therapists and occupational therapists for Eli, and I have to say they have been awesome. Eli loves it because they always make it super fun, I see progress from what they do, and it re-motivates me when I see the success they have with him. We just started OT again with him a month ago because he still has lots of issues with eating, and already I’ve seen huge progress in areas that I swear I’ve worked on my own with for months and months.
So, my suggestion would be that depending on your insurance and if you can afford the cost, I would do it. If it’s going to be hundreds of dollars a month, then maybe you can do something like go for a few weeks to get lots of input and ideas (with them fully aware you’re only going for a few weeks so that they can provide you extra resources and materials), then work on it for a few months on your own. Go back again for another few weeks to re-evaluate and get further direction on next steps.
And know that when you do get back to company X, therapy is totally paid for-and I have a great place that I LOVED that I’d be happy to refer you to
.
Really though Jenna, every kid is different and every kid learns at their own pace and in their own ways. He will catch up, and in no way is any of it your fault.
And sorry this comment was a novel.
Reply
October 10th, 2011 on 10:06 pm
I’ve worked with a ton of kids (thought later on in their development) with a few delays, and the vast majority of them have awesome, delightful, involved, and smart parents. Don’t beat yourself up, seriously. We all learn differently, and it’s great that you’ve been able to find out now and figure out what T1′s learning style is. There’s certainly nothing you did to cause it, or most likely could have done to prevent it, but there is something you can do about it now, and that’s pretty awesome.
As an educator, I’d say go with the therapy now — particularly with language skills, the earlier they start the better (just like learning a second language)! I’ll pray for you guys and I hope that you’ll feel a bit better in the morning. He’s a beautiful healthy baby and I bet this is just a little bump in the road.
Reply
October 10th, 2011 on 10:12 pm
Jenna, there is no doubt that you are are a good mom. Believe me when I say that you have not ruined your child! As a speech therapist, I would not put off therapy for a year. Early intervention is important, and it sounds like, for the well being of your family, you need the support eci can offer at this time. Even if you have to scrimp and pinch to make it work, I think you will be glad you did.
Reply
Nisha Malavia Reply:
October 12th, 2011 at 10:50 am
Jenna,
I have to agree with Allison. I am also a speech therapist, and the longer you wait, the more there is a risk of larger gaps of a delay, which could ultimately be more costly (not trying to scare you, but it’s not really worth the risk). This is a great age to get therapy started so he can get on track. It could very well be that he’s exposed to 2 languages and he just needs to catch up or that he’s a late talker and it will resolve itself. However, it is a better idea to take advantage of Early Intervention. And please don’t feel guilty! I know it’s hard not to, but you do so much already and it’s important to think of what is great with T1 as opposed to what’s not. Feel free to e-mail me with any more questions, I’d be happy to help!
Reply
October 10th, 2011 on 10:17 pm
Hugs, everyone already said everything I was going to say especially about going through the public school system. Kids develop at different times. Grab some girlfriends and go get a hot chocolate and a pedicure.
Reply
October 10th, 2011 on 10:24 pm
There’s a blog I’ve followed for a long time called Me and Wee. Her daughter had some developmental delays but there is a lot you can do on your own! Read her posts on it here:
http://meandwee.blogspot.com/search/label/Communicating%20with%20Wee
Reply
Jenna Reply:
October 10th, 2011 at 10:50 pm
Thanks so much Bee. What she described regarding her daughter at 20 months sounds a lot like P at 18 (minus the desire her daughter had to play in the corner, P likes to engage with other kids). I’m really interested in the website she linked to, and in particular the DVDs. Playing with P is actually one of the things we struggle with because he either wants to do the same thing over and over, or he moves on before we are doing it for very long, which would be fine for a short while, but we want to see some progress over time and we haven’t really felt like we’ve seen that. I think I need some ideas on how to better play with him, how to speak to him while we were doing it. I mean, today we were pretending to sweep (well I was really sweeping and he was pretending) and I got down on the floor to praise him for helping, but the interaction just kind of ends there because I don’t know what to do next and he often just wants to take the broom back and run around the house with it. *sigh* I never knew play would be so difficult for me!
Reply
Sophia Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 6:29 am
First of all, I’m so sorry to hear that you’re going through all of this. I’m not a mom but I can only imagine all the emotions you’re going through.
Regarding the talking with/playing with children: I have always interacted with kids like little people, even if they didn’t understand our “conversations”. Just rambling, kind of. When I was babysitting, I would talk about everything we were doing. When I was changing her diaper, I’d talk about changing her diaper, when I was cooking, I’d talk about what I was chopping, how good it was going to be, etc. That is how I also interacted with my nephews. It was, perhaps, “incessant”, but to me it was just a vocalization of my internal dialogue, that also helped me to interact with the kiddos, since I felt awkward in the silence. My cousin did that with her kids as well. I’ve never been a “sing songy” voice/over animated type person, but stream of consciousness commentary on the day to day activities of life with a kid came naturally to me, so that’s what I did. I also really liked reading to them, because I could use silly voices and it feels less awkward than randomly thinking up strings of nonsense to sing song to them. Sometimes it was legit reading, other times it was silliness with the pictures, or acting out the characters, etc.
Every mom I know will totally admit that the things that fascinate their toddlers, and the playing they like to do, are not necessarily fun things for parents/adults, so don’t feel bad about that. They all just say that you figure out the best way to interact with them in a way that supports their play- I think that looks different to every parent. It’s mind numbing, to be sure, to continue to “surprise!” a toddler every.single.time. they come around the corner, but even older children-6,7- are obsessed with repetition and will often repeat the same silly phrases over and over, or do the same silly things, and they never seem to tire of it. It’s important and fun to *them*, so the best we can do is figure out a way to enjoy that interaction (which can for sure sometimes be challenging!). I hope that the therapists can help you out, and at least you know what you need to do, and where to start. I really think that this is going to end up being a great thing for T1, and for your family. I agree with other comments that I do think you should start soon, especially since the speech therapist specifically wants to.
I woke up at 3 a.m. this morning and have yet to be able to go back to sleep and it’s 5:30 a.m., so apologizes if the above is rambly/disjointed
Reply
Jessica @ One Shiny Star Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 1:07 pm
This is so true, and very important for language development. It can get annoying, but imagine that he is already asking “why”. So every time you do something with him, answer “why” you are doing it. “We’re sweeping the floor, good job! Do you know why we are sweeping?” I do this is my normal voice, as if I were telling a toddler who could already understand and ask the question themselves. Once he’s old enough he will start asking “why?” to everything, so it also helps to get in the habit of patiently answering the question now - while offering a view into not only language, but how the world works.
It’s also important for him to hear conversations. Kids that babble, with do so with sentence structure, for example, when they are babbling a question it will go up in pitch at the end - just like we do in spoken English. This is a key to language and so demonstrating asking and answering questions will help him to pick up on how conversations go. (All of this is making me miss my undergrad classes!).
Reply
Rachel Reply:
October 12th, 2011 at 5:21 am
Loved these 2 comments. I rarely speak to my children in real sing-songy voice. I just speak to them normally. We read a lot of books (Over and over and over sometimes. I really want to burn a few of the books we have), we sing a lot of songs (Also over and over and over sometimes. They do love repitition!), and I just narrate a lot. I don’t think you have to incessantly talk to them. Just if you’ve noticed you haven’t been talking a whole lot- start explaining what you are doing or what you’re going to be doing. It’s awkward sometimes and can feel silly but they don’t care. I do it at the grocery store and then feel embarrassed for talking to a 2 year old and 1 year old. Any moms or dads there just smile and laugh because they’ve been there too.
Reply
Jessica @ One Shiny Star Reply:
October 12th, 2011 at 9:39 am
I do that too at the grocery store… but my baby is only 3 months old. lol.
Reply
October 10th, 2011 on 10:29 pm
I know we only get to see a small sliver of your life here, but from what I’ve seen you’re a good mom. No matter what you do or don’t do it seems there will always be mommy-guilt.
Every child develops differently, and I know that a lot of children who come from bilingual homes can have a delay when it comes to talking.
I’ve been talking to two different speech pathologists recently (they’re family friends, and if you have specific questions I can pass them along), and one of the things they’ve both stressed was to talk, talk, talk, talk to your child. I’m sure you know this, but make sure you’re talking *to* them, not just around them; narrate what you’re doing, start labeling everything around you.
I also want to say that T1 is ADORABLE in that video.
Reply
October 10th, 2011 on 10:36 pm
Jenna, don’t let yourself feel guilty over this. You have done everything you can to provide T1 with the best environment possible, but not everyone flourishes at the same speed. But please do consider finding a way to make therapy fit into the budget now; the earlier intervention happens, the more successful it is. And even though you have NOTHING to feel guilty about now, you may feel much guiltier later knowing that you could have started therapy but didn’t. I second (third? fourth?) the comment about going through public schools as well; my mother is a school psychologist working with a lot of developmentally delayed children, and I know in her school districts, home occupational/speech therapists are available, even well before the child hits school age (it is easier and less expensive for the school district to intervene early for a few years, rather than wait until the child is older and require many more years of treatment).
Reply
October 10th, 2011 on 10:39 pm
Jenna, I’m just proud of you for admitting there is a problem now, and not once he gets in school. I work with some of the kids at my school with auditory processing disorders, and it’s difficult to help the child when the parents won’t admit there is a problem and aren’t willing to get help they need. There is one child in our program with a horrible speech impediment as well as an auditory processing disorder and his parents aren’t willing to get him help because he will “grow out of it” (it hasn’t gotten better in the last 3 years!). I would suggest getting help ASAP, and possibly working with the local schools. I know our speech therapist also works with pre-schoolers so it’s an option!
Reply
D Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 1:08 am
This. I’ve seen a couple parents who have pretended that their children are “ok” and just mildly delayed (which does occur!) when the experts tell them that their children have issues like autism so much that they hide it from their spouses.
I’m so glad you had the courage to stick your head out of the sand and be willing to find a solution! lots of hugs!
Reply
October 10th, 2011 on 10:47 pm
Jenna, picking on yourself won’t make it any better. Forgive yourself. You’re not perfect and that’s okay. He’ll be fine in the long run, I’m sure. If I were your mother, I would tell you this: if you can do something about it, don’t worry about it. If you can’t do something about it, don’t worry about it. And then, I would tell you to remember who you are (the answer is a daughter of God.) Pray it out and rely on the Lord. It’s okay if life is hard, there’s nothing wrong with that. It’ll all be okay.
Reply
October 10th, 2011 on 10:48 pm
Mommy guilt is the worst. At my daughter’s 15mo check-up our ped noticed that she was crossing one eye. I had never noticed it and felt horrible for not seeing it. I mean I spend every day with her. How could I not have seen that? We were sent to a ped opthamologist and it turned out that she was extremely far sighted and needed glasses. I cried the whole ride home like it was the end of the world (I was also pregnant with our 2nd at the time). Once we got the glasses a whole world opened up for her because she could actually see. Now we even have to do some patching for
My point is that once T1 gets the help he needs,I bet you’ll be amazed how quickly he turns the corner on this delay. Catching things early is the best possible scenario.
Reply
Chantal Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 1:35 pm
My daughter had the exact same thing happen. She has accommodative presbyopia. She was extremely far-sighted, glasses helped. We patched for a bit and then they decided to have surgery on the eye muscle a year ago. She now wears bifocals and we still have some crossing of the eyes. We actual have another appointment today to decide if they are going to do another surgery. She is 4 years old now. I beat myself up too wondering what I did wrong when I was pregnant with her… I was bad at taking my prenatal vitamins because they made me sick and I wanted to blame myself thinking that because of that, she has bad eyes. And yes, things are best when caught early and fixed when they are young.
Reply
October 10th, 2011 on 10:51 pm
I’m sorry you’re hurting, but I also think that Mommy Guilt isn’t always a bad thing. You haven’t done anything wrong, and you didn’t ruin him… but feeling crummy now will spur you to continue to be better, for P. You’re a good Mama, but we can always be better. The knowledge you gained today is a tool you can use to be better.
That said… I’m with previous comments. No way would I delay therapy for a year. These are the formative times. It may mean sacrifices, but if you can do it now, do it now.
Reply
phruphru Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 8:23 am
I agree with everything in this comment. Jenna, I love your blog and even though you and I have very different ideas about some things, I think I’d like you a lot if we ever met in person. I like that you have firm beliefs and convictions and respect all the research you do about everything.
So you know I’m not a hater and that I come from a good place: Get your baby the therapy, ASAP. Skip the dinner at Alinea, dip into savings (you’ve said before that you guys have a good amount of liquid savings — this is what savings are for!). As Chelsea says, use the mommy guilt for good purposes. Little P is probably just fine — we’ve all heard so many stories about toddlers who don’t speak at all and then bust out full sentences — but why take the risk?
Reply
October 10th, 2011 on 10:56 pm
Motherhood is full of guilt. Most of the time we spread that nasty little feeling all over ourselves like great smelling lotion. Guilt can be good or bad. If it moves us forward into positive behavior is can be a motivator. Or it can be paralyzing by throwing us in a dark hole of despair. You are smart and have resources at your fingertips, you believe in a higher power which can bring you comfort and you have a great husband to support you. Use what you have been blessed with and give that sweet little boy all the things you have.
From His perspective: It must be frustration not being able to communicate. He wants to tell you, he just does not have the skills to do so. Other than his bottle, a clean diaper, lunch and sleep I think he would ask for help to speak to you. Don’t wait-he has so many other things in life to learn and maybe, just maybe some of them can not be mastered until he moves past this bump in the road. Chin up! You can do this.
Reply
Jenna Reply:
October 10th, 2011 at 11:03 pm
Gracias mama
I really am doing ok, not crying or anything, just frustrated that I didn’t fix this myself or something. I don’t know. You told me this motherhood thing would be hard, but I didn’t realize what that meant.
I tried to call you today, just so you know I was going to tell you myself so you didnt learn all this online
. I will call you when I get the paper that they mail me that summarizes the meeting.
Maybe this means he’ll be chatting up a storm by Christmas!
Reply
October 10th, 2011 on 11:02 pm
I think you should take a few weeks and get some distance from the appointment before you make any decisions. Children develop at different paces. My son (2 1/2 now) spoke only 2 or 3 words up until he turned 2 and rarely unprompted. I worried that he was developmentally delayed and beat myself up over what I could do differently to try to fix what I had broken. (Especially because I have a daughter 15 months younger than him. Was I going to break her too?) At 12 months our doctor mentioned she was concerned with his lack of speech. We moved to a new state and our new pediatrician (who takes a more holistic approach to medicine) was not concerned at 15 months but wanted to revisit the situation at 18 months. By 18 months my son had progressed in other ways, he wasn’t broken, he was busy learning many different things. He was busy learning how to climb and manipulate things and how to do so many other things. Our doctor explained that a lot of children get focused on different skills and ‘fall behind’ on others. A month or so after he turned 2 my son exploded with words and now a few more months later he’s speaking in sentences and helping me teach his little sister new words. Before 2 he couldn’t pick out many pictures or fetch toys but he was actively learning other skills. I’m not saying T1 isn’t delayed but he may not be delayed in a way that means he needs therapy. Obviously you have and will continue to do what’s in his best interest, you know him better than anyone. Your intuition is stronger than you think. Trust it and let go of what other people say is ‘normal.’ If you can see he’s not progressing in other ways, then take the next step and try therapy. You aren’t a bad mother, you are a wonderful mother who cares deeply about the little person you are helping to shape.
Reply
LPC Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 12:58 pm
This. Exactly this. Maybe P. will have some real language issues over time. Maybe not. I have to say that from the video he appears to be very bright. Look at the fine motor coordination, the game with the bottles he is playing. Look at how he can actually walk in a bathtub without slipping! I’d be more concerned about how he does with cognitive challenges than language alone. Just make sure you are working with very good people. I know you will.
As for playing with kids, I remember the early child people talking about “language-rich” environments. Just narrate to him everything he’s doing. “Oh I see you P! Now you are carrying the broom. Now you are running. Are you running? Are you running?” Kind of silly, but you can do a lot and still keep up the running monologue. Eventually it may turn into a dialogue.
Reply
October 10th, 2011 on 11:03 pm
Jenna! Of course you didn’t ruin him, he’s amazing. First of all, think of all the children who grew up 100 or 50 or even 10 years ago who didn’t have early intervention specialists come to their homes and analyze their children. I can guarantee that most of those children grew up with no lasting effects of whatever “delays” they may have suffered.
That said, if you and TH decide that pursuing therapy is the best choice for your family, I think that getting into it as soon as possible is your best bet. The program should be able to guide you through the process of finding out what is covered through insurance. Medicaid can also cover some services. Google parent groups in your area as they can be a huge help in finding therapists and navigating the process.
Jenna, you are a fantastic mother! You and your family will get through this. : )
Reply
October 10th, 2011 on 11:04 pm
Jenna you are such a good momma. Don’t feel guilty over this! T1 is going to be just fine. I’ll be praying for ya girl!
Reply
October 10th, 2011 on 11:06 pm
You are a great mother, and one of the reasons that we can tell that is because you are admitting that something may be wrong and considering options to help out T1. Throughout his life, you’ll be reminded that he’s his own person with his own needs and that the best (and hardest) parenting decisions will require you to move outside what you know and are comfortable with and do what’s best for him. So far you are passing this test with flying colors…No one expects you to do it alone, and you won’t have to.
I don’t know how helpful anecdotes are to you right now, but I will say my brother didn’t speak until he was over 2 years old and then when he did speak his first words were a complete sentence. He’s an EXTREMELY verbal person- funny, confident, and simply brilliant at clear off-the-cuff public speaking. He has several advanced degrees and is an executive at a major company. I know that you’re worried about T1, but I just wanted to remind you that you’re doing the absolute best by finding out IF sometimes wrong and how best to proceed from tehre. Best wishes to all of you.
Reply
October 10th, 2011 on 11:07 pm
As a graduate student in the process of becoming a speech pathologist, allow me to offer you some advice: get off of the internet. Stop writing in your blog and talk to your child. Stop going out to expensive dinners, stop taking trips to Europe, and care for your child. Do not put off speech therapy. There is a reason why the speech therapist who you had your session with is against delaying therapy. Help your child while he is still young. Read to him. Talk to him. Sing to him. Practice naming tasks. Help him work on his comprehensive and expressive language. Practice signing. Your blog shows how negligent of a parent you are and how little interest you show in your own child. I am so passionate about communication disorders, and it genuinely disturbs me to see the way that you are handling this situation. All of your expenses should be moved to the backburner; all of your efforts should be focused on providing your child with the help that he needs. If it means that you have to go without new clothes or a new cell phone, so be it. Learn what it means to be a parent.
As for the guilt, you SHOULD feel guilty. You SHOULD feel guilty about the fact that the way that you have parented your son has led to his being developmentally delayed. You SHOULD feel guilty that you have not interacted with your son enough to help him develop his language skills. The amount of language that babies hear plays a HUGE role in language acquisition, and you have failed in that area. You SHOULD feel guilty about that. But you know what? You should use that guilt in a productive way. Allow it to make you a better parent. Remember what it feels like to have so tremendously failed your son in such an important area of his life. Remember it and use it. Use it to help you make the decision to make his therapy your number one concern. Use it to help you make the decision to sacrifice time on the internet to read, play, and interact with your son. Use it to help you become a better mother.
The fact that your actions (or, in the case, the lack thereof) have negatively impacted your son’s life is not the end of the world. It should be the beginning for you. Please get your son the help that he needs as soon as possible.
Reply
Jenna Reply:
October 10th, 2011 at 11:24 pm
I consider this comment to be a cowardly disgrace to your future profession. If you treated an actual client this way I would report you to your supervisors and advise my friends to never get the evaluation in the first place.
I have deleted at least 10 comments just like this, some worse, more cutting, more demeaning, more spiteful, and I don’t understand your purpose. This is how you think you affect positive change in the world? By hiding behind a mask of anonymity and making women who already feel vulnerable cry?
I really, really want you to think about what comments like this do. If you were a true professional you would know that you represent everyone in your field, kind people who are genuinely trying to make the world a better place by using kindness and support. You would have taken the time to leave a comment that talked about resources I could look toward, and you would have used positive reinforcement and constructive criticism as a true professional would do (like the women who came to my home today).
Instead you judged and you trolled and you hated. Just despicable.
And you can tell all your little friends that this is as much air-time as you guys are getting. Keep coming over though, I like having the increase in hits
Reply
Eliza Reply:
October 10th, 2011 at 11:46 pm
It’s honestly so strange to me that you make yourself out to be the victim in this situation. Do you want to know who the victim is? Your son. Do you think that it bothers me that people who are addressing this, quite frankly, horrific example of negligence, are making you cry? It doesn’t. More to the point, my comment was not even “mean,” but because I wasn’t patting you on the back and telling you that you’ve done everything that you possibly could for your child (you obviously haven’t), I’ve been accused of trolling and hating. I did neither. I advised you on what you could do to improve your situation. If you had taken the time to think critically or perhaps analyze what I had said as opposed to immediately getting defensive, it would have been pretty obvious to you that I was telling you that yes, you may have failed previously, but it is also an opportunity for you to make positive changes.
If you were a client of mine, yes, I’m sure that I would treat you differently. As it stands, you are a selfish, self-involved mother more interested in blogging than in taking adequate care of your child. I do not have sympathy for someone like you, nor does it bother me that I do not have your respect. At the end of the day, I know that I have the best interests of CHILDREN in mind, and that is something that someone like you could not possibly take away from me.
I really do wish you all the best and hope that you will somehow wake up and look at this situation for what it truly is instead of feeling sorry for yourself. Be proactive.
Reply
Kimberly Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 12:31 am
Do you follow Jenna’s blog? Do you realize that T1 has grandparents in Europe that were thrilled to see him (or is visiting family detrimental to children)? That Jenna can afford to eat an expensive dinner once in a blue moon because she eats at home the rest of the time? That most of her clothing posts are about thrifted items? I don’t know her blogging habits, but I do know plenty of mothers who manage to blog when their children are asleep. How is that detrimental to the child? What makes you think she doesn’t read/talk/sing to him?
Your comments don’t seem applicable at all.
Reply
Kira Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 12:33 am
Wow, are you honestly implying that every child who experiences speech delays has “negligent” parents? If this is truly your view, you may want to reconsider your profession. Spend a few years working in the field and see where this attitude gets you.
Reply
Eliza Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 12:45 am
No, I’m really not. Perhaps you misread my comment. In this SPECIFIC case, I do think that the fact that this woman APPEARS to spend a limited amount of time interacting with her child has contributed a great deal to the fact that his language is delayed. I am very aware of the fact that cultural, familial, and SES differences impact children in a vast number of ways. Thank you for your concern regarding my education and career choices.
Reply
Katy Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 7:01 am
You have not experienced the world have you? Are you a parent yourself? You throw around the word negligence like it is somehow a great umbrella term for your disagreement with her parenting. But negligence is a term reserved for the real evils in the world perpetrated by actual bad parents. Maybe in your sphere a bad parent is one that only talked to their child a total of 5,000 times instead of 7,000 but talk to any social worker, court worker, or cop and you’ll find out what REAL negligence is and send Jenna a thank you note for being a good mom.
NO parent is perfect and *every* *single* *parent* out there since the beginning of time has things they might not do as well as others, but they make up for it by being better at other things. Don’t throw this word “negligence” around as if you know what you are talking about.
Reply
Coasting anon Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 7:31 am
Amen, Katy. Come back, Eliza, when you 1) have an idea of what REAL negligence is 2) can act like the professional you claim you are and 3) aren’t hiding behind a veil of anonymity…
You are a coward.
Reply
Danielle Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 12:25 pm
Dude, Eliza, I totally laughed when I read this. You sound so silly and ridiculous. Something APPEARING (caps and all) a certain way has never contributed a great deal to much of anything. You shot your whole argument in the foot right here. It *appears* to you that Jenna fails to do this or that blah blah blah. But that doesn’t matter at all. What matters is what she *actually* fails to do and what she *actually* accomplishes. And I’d be willing to bet that she exceeds the baseline expectations of parental involvement with their kids and their development. She just has little boy who needs some extra help and tools.
Reply
Mary Cyrus Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 12:56 am
The fact that a stay-at-home mother writes a blog does not make her negligent. Not by a long shot. I’m sure she puts a good hour or two (or more) into many of her posts, but compare that to a child with two parents working outside the home. Would you also accuse a working mother of being negligent if her child was developmentally delayed? Or is it the fact that what Jenna chooses to devote her time to might be considered frivolous or unnecessary and you judge that?
My sister has a 5-year-old son who is extremely developmentally delayed; as in will not ever speak aloud and most likely will not ever walk. In his case, this has everything to do with a genetic condition and nothing to do with the fact that my sister blogs everyday, in addition to hustling him to therapy appointments and medical specialists galore, to say nothing of resuscitating him from apneic seizures. Blogging does not equal negligence. Period.
You judge based on what you read here, but you are not in Jenna’s home. It frankly scares me that this is your profession of choice if you possess so little compassion. I don’t know; there may be some modicum of truth to what you say. I’m not in Jenna’s home either. I do know that the confrontational, demeaning way in which you made your points is mean, unnecessary, and completely unproductive.
Reply
Eliza Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 1:21 am
I’m not going to address most of the comment because, to be frank, I don’t really care, but I’d like to point out that I have PLENTY of compassion. Unfortunately for Jenna, my compassion is for her child who sleeps in a bathroom because his mother is too selfish to give him a bedroom, a child who is given so little attention from his parents that he does not recognize them after being apart, a child who does not have toys because his mother does not want to have to pick them up. I have a great deal of compassion. Thank you for your concern.
Reply
Senora H-B Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 7:40 am
You’re kidding, right? Please tell me you’re kidding.
How is it selfish to have a baby sleep in a dark, quiet bathroom rather than a too-brightly-lit bedroom?
An 18-month-old that doesn’t recognize his parents after two weeks apart. Do you actually know any 18-month-olds?
My baby sisters FREAKED out when I cut my hair because they didn’t recognize me. They wouldn’t go anywhere near my dad when he returned after a week-long business trip. I guess you’d tell me that my dad was a negligent parent?
A child who doesn’t have an obscene number of toys but thoroughly enjoys playing with the ones he has? Heaven forbid!
I suppose you can put your spin on whatever you choose from Jenna’s life.
I’d encourage Jenna to take your diagnoses and judgments with a massive grain of salt. You are basing your words on a sliver of someone’s life. I sincerely hope that you change your attitude toward parents before you begin practicing. I can’t imagine that you’d have any kind of success with your attitude.
Reply
Caitlin Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 1:21 am
As a speech language pathologist, I agree 100% with you Jenna! I can’t believe someone would choose to represent ME this way. Eliza, I feel sorry for you. But mostly, I feel sorry for your current and future clients.
Jenna, you absolutely should not feel guilty. You have no education in child development and have managed to raise a HEALTHY, LOVED, LOVING, and SOCIAL child. That is wonderful! That being said, PLEASE do not delay therapy for T1. $30 dollars a month really is small price (I was actually shocked to read that it was so little). The longer you delay therapy, most likely, the further behind T1 will fall. SLPs have extensive education (at least 6 years) in speech, language, and cognitive development. Therapy at your son’s age is as much about you as it is your child! Your son will play to learn while you will learn to play!
Some other people have mentioned that the school-system provides therapy also. That is a great recommendation and I second it whole-heartedly. (In fact I would recommend putting him in private and school-based therapy.
Also, maybe look into the universities in Chicago. Universities with SLP programs often have on-site clinics where graduate students provided therapy closely supervised by experts in the field. This could be a hit or miss as the therapist that work closely with you and your son is still learning, but the newest techniques and evidence based therapies are often the ones being taught and used.
One easy thing that you can start doing right away is narrating everything you do and everything T1 does. It’s pretty simple and doesn’t take any time away from you- you’re already doing something, so just talk!
Also, I wanted to clarify the two-language bit of info floating around… Research has shown that children without any delays tend to sort the languages out themselves and that it really does not delay the child significantly. It seems that children tend to mix the two languages rather than not being able to use either for a while. So please don’t feel as if that in any way caused your son’s delays. That being said, you may want to focus on one language, but that really is a personal decision.
Finally, if you’d like, please feel free to email me if you have any questions. I really hope that your future encounters with SLPs will empower you like Shanna said.
Reply
Caitlin Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 1:24 am
Woops, I made a mistake- It’s not 6 years. I have no idea why I typed that. It was 4 years for me- 2 years in undergrad and a 2 year Masters program.
Reply
allison Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 11:59 am
No worries, it was 6 years for me and probably for many or most SLPs.
Reply
Caitlin Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 2:59 pm
Yup, 6 years total for me too- 4 years dedicated to speech, language, cognition, etc…
Reply
Amber Reply:
October 12th, 2011 at 11:33 am
It is six years in my province - 4 years undergrad, and 2 in a masters program!
Reply
allison Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 11:57 am
Jenna, I’ve been thinking about your post all morning, so I came back on my lunch break to find that Caitlin has already said many of the things I was thinking. Thanks, Caitlin!
One thing to add about university clinics: they may have a sliding pay scale. I know we did in the clinic where I did my graduate training. But really, $30/month seems like a steal.
I found this website that has a list of the universities in Illinois that offer speech language pathology degrees. Hopefully it will help narrow your search. http://www.ishail.org/isha/learn_ektid162.aspx
Reply
Caitlin Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 3:06 pm
Yes, thank you! That was the point I failed to make in bringing up the universities. It is typically cheaper. But I can’t imagine it being cheaper than $30/month.
Reply
Shanna Reply:
October 10th, 2011 at 11:31 pm
Wow. I think you need to back away from your comment and re-read it while practicing some empathy. You’ll need it to become a successful professional, and I think you’ll learn that drowning someone in guilt (deserved or not) is a powerful way to drain someone of motivation. You are entitled to your opinion, but think of the mother you are talking to and try to phrase things in a way that will empower her to help in the future. I would also like to point out that you should perhaps reserve judgement until you see the whole picture, which we can’t through a blog.
Reply
Stephanie C Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 12:25 am
I’d like to add that it’s also extremely important during these times to encourage familial support. I’m not sure how the bad attitude is helping the situation. You can’t fault someone for not being as knowledgable about this issue as you may be.
One of the most important things we as professionals working in this arena should be learning in our programs is to communicate our ideas with respect and not assume everyone is as informed as we are.
In addition, it’s pretty presumptuous to say that Jenna is completely neglecting her child and has all her attention on the blog - we get little snippets of her life.
Reply
D Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 1:15 am
I think even more importantly, Eliza. No matter if you thought this. There were many other kinder ways of saying this. Jenna already has said maybe she needs to spend more time talking T1 and that she feels guilty. She is aware and she is addressing the issue.
I think you could had said you were concerned but I really wished you knew how hard Jenna tries and how hard it is as a parent to face this type of situation.
Reply
Marissa C Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 10:25 am
Wow. What an ignorant comment (from Eliza). So what about working moms? I’m sure Jenna is around her child more than any working mom and I wouldn’t blame them. Someone’s blog does not give us a 100% view of their life. It’s bits and pieces. Lord help me if anyone judges me by my blog alone!
Reply
Sara Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 1:06 pm
Yes, this is a hideous example of shaming and blaming someone who doesn’t deserve it for an instant. Jenna is a mother who works at home - and I wonder how she could be less ‘negligent’. Should she never work at her photography business and never contribute an income to her family? Should she never write here, which clearly makes her happy and contributes to her business? She she *really* never spend a single second taking care of herself? Is that really what we’re suggesting?
And what about TH? If we’re going down this idiotic road, why aren’t we blaming him for ‘neglect’? He’s out of the house every day, did he ‘fail’ here too? What about when they have more children, or what if their circumstances changed, and they had to put T1 in daycare and both work? Is that terrible parenting? Because if so, there are an awful lot of terrible parents.
Stupid, just stupid. No one can, or should, give 100% of their attention to their child 100% of the time. Everyone has to work, and to relax, and to do things that make them happy and that feed their soul. To suggest that Jenna is a bad parent because she blogs here most days is sexist, unfeminist, and downright offensive. So she should maybe talk to him a little more. BFD - now she knows. Judge not, folks.
Reply
Heather S Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 12:29 pm
Eliza-The question that keeps coming to my mind is, are you a parent? I understand that you are training to WORK with children, but have you ever actually RAISED one? If not, than I believe it is quite ridiculous for you to make judgements about Jenna’s parenting skills. Do you think that you leaving nasty comments on Jenna’s blog will make a positive impact on T1′s life? I don’t think so. So then I question your motive. Surely you didn’t leave this comment just to be hurtful?
Reply
LPC Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 1:01 pm
Huh? How the heck does this women think she knows enough to say this? Why doesn’t she want to talk about how physical able P. seems to be, huh?
Reply
tara Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 1:30 pm
agree 1000%. especially with the first few sentences- i think that all the time when i read this blog. you talk so much about being in grad school, having a ‘student’s budget’ lifestyle, and being frugal, but then boast about weeks-long trips to europe, meals that cost hundreds of dollars, csa’s, your personal trainer. makes me want to barf. as a med-student wife living on a REAL student budget, here’s something i’ve learned. sacrifice. kinda helps with the whole mommy thing too. and to the above poster… i’m not sure what ‘physical able’ means… but if you mean physically able… that kinda has nothing to do with speech/cognition… anyone can grow a kid physically- food, water, sleep. that’s it. it takes a lot more for emotional and cognitive development.
Reply
Marissa C Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 3:47 pm
I’m a med-student wife as well…one budget does not fit all. Jenna has posted many times about how they have less in certain areas in order to have more in others. We don’t know her budget. We don’t know how much she spends on a day-to-day basis. There is nothing wrong with splurging occasionally if you can afford it. And let’s face it…that’s the sort of thing you WANT to blog about.
Reply
Bethany Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 6:34 pm
Why does everyone keep brining up Jenna’s trips to Europe? Remember how TH is Polish and his family LIVES there? It’s not like they are irresponsibly galavanting across the world without regard for T1! They are visiting family! I would say that NOT going is more irresponsible. T1 needs to know his grandparents and his grandparents need to have time with him. Your comment is so narrow it makes ME want to barf.
Not saying this is the case, but have you ever considered that Jenna & TH may get help with their expenses traveling to visit family? I know when I visit my parents they help me out because they want to see me and otherwise I wouldn’t be able to get there very often. I’m not saying this to discount the saving that I’m sure Jenna & TH do for these trips… but you must think before you make judgements about things you know nothing about.
Also, I participate in a CSA and with careful planning, it doesn’t add much to my grocery budget. Plus, T1 gets healthy, organic food prepared by Jenna every day to keep him healthy. But I guess offering nourishment to your kids doesn’t count since you say that “anyone can grow a kid”. And BTW, physical development IS a big deal for growing kids. Many kids experience real physical delays equal to T1′s speech delay that are just as difficult and painful for parents to deal with (as many moms on this blog have attested to). You obviously don’t have kids so stop the judgement!
Reply
October 10th, 2011 on 11:08 pm
Jenna! I am the one who has been repeatedly asking you questions about this on your formspring (maybe there are more than one of us, if so I’m one of them). We are going through the same thing with our daughter, 16 months. I was SHOCKED at her 12 month appointment because they were very nervous about her speech development, and I had no idea that anything was wrong. We went through about the same process that you describe here, and she was found to be “developmentally delayed” in her speech, and we currently have a speech therapist come to our house twice a month to work with her.
We feel the same way you describe - if I had talked to her MORE, worked HARDER on sign language, read more books then she would be talking and so this must be all my fault. I feel bad when the speech therapist comes, too - is that how I should be playing with her all the time? Because that would be exhausting and I start to think I’m not cut out for this! It’s hard to even “forgive” myself for these things because it’s impossible to know what went wrong/if what we are trying now is really working or this is the time she was always meant to say “eye” and that’s why she said it. I feel the same feelings of guilt about a potential second baby, too. What if second baby talks at the “right” time? Is it because I was better with second baby? Because second baby had a sibling to talk to? (all this hand-wringing over a baby that doesn’t exist!)
Anyway, super-long comment, BUT I’m glad you chose to write about this because I’m obviously very interested, and I think it’s important to hear from another mother who feels like me. It’s so hard to read my girlfriend’s blog with videos of her 10 month old saying words and making animal sounds, so this is a nice balance
Can you see my e-mail on this thing? Let me know if you need to talk/vent/commiserate
Reply
October 10th, 2011 on 11:32 pm
After I commented I went back to read through the other comments. Yikes! I’m sure there are people who will read my above comment and be horrified that I waited to see if he would grow out of it. Well, I chose to wait it out a little longer because I felt he was progressing in other ways. I made sure to check in with my pediatrician about the situation. I wasn’t worried because my son was on track or ahead of schedule in other ways, with other skills. Obviously, every situation is different. I was lucky enough to have people in my life who had similar situations. Some did therapy and some waited. Some of the friends I spoke to who encouraged therapy because their children were speaking in sentences at 12 months now have children who are behind in gross and fine motor skills, some have children who have remained on track the whole time, some are like mine and were delayed in language and caught up, and some have children who have been delayed in many areas and continue to show delays. For those who worry I was a horrible mother who just ignored the delays, my son is now 2 1/2 and testing at age 4 for most of his skills. We’ve started Tot School with him and my 15 month old. If you want ideas for playful learning check out some of the Tot School blogs. I have liked http://theprincessandthetot.blogspot.com/ and http://totallytots.blogspot.com/. They also have links to many other Tot School sites. Good luck!
Reply
October 10th, 2011 on 11:43 pm
I nannied for a little girl starting at 18mo and all she could say was no. but it wasnt even “no” it was just a sound that to her meant no. Either way the doctors were worried but her mom just figured it was timing. She was right. She just turned 3 and is a little chatterbox. I wouldnt stress too much. Seek Heavenly Fathers guidance about how you can help him progress and I am sure it will all work out:)
Reply
October 10th, 2011 on 11:58 pm
Oh Jenna, this is how I have felt for the last month and a half it is the pits. My son (14 mos) has similar issues (although he is hard of hearing) and tests at a 6 mos speech and 9 mos cognitive, it was a hard pill to swallow. I still blame myself at times, I probably always will simply because I knew that something was wrong and I trusted his dr.(who spent maybe 20 mins at a time) when he said my son was fine.That being said every child has their own version of “normal”, there is no set time line. While this may effect him now, it probably won’t cause much of an issue later on. I have met several children with similar issues to T1 and my son that have made huge leaps and bounds with the help of therapy. If you can’t afford it try seeing if he can be covered by state insurance for the time being? The more you work with him now while he is young the quicker he may pick it up. Children are resilient and amazing; T1 will probably be talking your ear off soon and then you will wish he wasn’t talking
.
Reply
October 11th, 2011 on 12:03 am
i remember picking out the polo in the first shot. I loved it then, but it is even cuter with the collar popped. He is looking like they actually fit and are not drowning him anymore. I have never seen him talk so much as that bath video. He grew so tall while you were in Europe. He doesn’t look like a baby anymore.
Don’t forget some of the most important words to teach him before Christmas - Nana & Grandpa!
Reply
October 11th, 2011 on 12:11 am
P.S. I think it is the mother in you to be so hard on yourself and so worried about him. But it really does surprise me that you are so worried about him not being in the “norm”, that is not something you generally care about. Look at you the protective mother!
This is my favorite comment by M:
“Frankly, there’s no way I would delay therapy for my child in this situation.”
I can’t decide if they are trying to be mean, or just stating their opinion.
Reply
M Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 1:17 pm
I’m not sure how my previous comment could be considered mean, but whatever. I have a son one month younger than T1 - I was very concerned about his language development until he started talking quite a bit just recently (like, I was preparing to ask my doctor about the same program T1 was evaluated by). And there is no way I would delay any treatment he needed if there was any way that I could afford it and make it work. Early Intervention is reportedly a great program that helps most kids a lot.
Reply
Shaylene Carter Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 1:34 pm
I apologize for thinking it was possibly mean. I was on the defensive last night after reading a very rude comment.
Reply
October 11th, 2011 on 12:12 am
When I learned my son is autistic, I had the same feelings and Jenna, it is so normal. With early intervention my son has thrived and so will T1. At age 4 my son is talking so well. Be thankful we’re living in a time when we have a wealth of information to help our kids!
Reply
October 11th, 2011 on 12:18 am
Jenna, I know you know this already, but ignore the trolls and the self-professed professionals (that Eliza needs to get off the internet, learn some empathy, or better yet get a new profession). My best friend Gillian is a Harvard-educated professor of English who reads a bazillion books to her son, interacts with him all the time, and is a spectacular mother. That didn’t stop her son from being speech-delayed. He got excellent testing from professionals in Rochester, where they live; was diagnosed with mild Asperger’s; and now has access to amazing educational resources that are helping him to acquire language and to interact socially. Being a good mother means doing exactly what you and Gillian are doing: reading prolifically, being open to testing and learning (without guilt, shame, or embarrassment), and engaging with a community of people who are experiencing similar issues.
Reply
Stephanie C Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 12:27 am
Well said!
Reply
October 11th, 2011 on 12:21 am
I don’t want to say that I’m an expert here, but I do have some experience working with speech delayed children, kids with autism, etc.
I want to encourage you to not consider putting this off. I’m not going to berate you as a mom like the other grad student did! I think you’ve done a great job, and sometimes there’s nothing more you can do. But the one important thing you can do here is to do the therapy. Early Intervention has been proven to help children.. the earlier the better. Putting it off will make it harder for him to catch on as he gets older.
I don’t know what it’s like in Chicago, but in L.A. there are regional centers that can give you more information..regarding financial issues and what your options are. I would encourage you to look into whether your city has something like that or not.
Reply
October 11th, 2011 on 12:29 am
Dont Worry, not yet at least, he is young he is a boy and some talk non stop and some point and grunt! My son is 20 months and not a talker he is just now getting some words and he does not use them all the time and has never said mummy, mamma, mum but he does say daddy! At about 16 months I was worried about his development and tantrums but in the last 4 months it has started to get better. I have not taken him to see the doctor because he does not need it yet he is bound to be a little slow as was born in the netherlands and now lives in Paris and we are English. I also am not good at the non stop chatter with him so maybe that is why? But he will talk and he will be fine, in many other countries a speech therapist would not be called in for at least another year,
Take Care
Reply
October 11th, 2011 on 12:32 am
Jenna, I am sorry to hear about your son’s challenges. I agree with most of the other comments that he will probably outgrow it with time and some extra help. He seems like a happy and active little boy judging from the video, so even if his speech is behind you are doing something right! I do think that early intervention is really important, so if you can possibly swing it financially I wouldn’t wait. Is buying supplemental insurance for T1 an option? Insuring children tends to be cheap.
I’m also sorry to hear about your emotional problems. Most aspects of children’s development and personality are genetic, especially when they are small. While nobody is a perfect parent and there’s always room for improvement, a lot is just out of our control as parents. My daughter is relatively advanced, but it’s not because I am so awesome, it’s just the way she’s wired. And I truly believe that T1′s problems are the same: you didn’t cause anything bad to happen, it’s just how his genes/tendencies are expressing themselves.
I think it’s really important as a parent not to take responsibility/credit on for either your children’s successes OR their challenges. Of course we must help them to the best of our ability, but please remember that even as the world’s best parent ever, your control is so limited. Sometimes this is a scary thought (because it means you can’t protect your children fully, and can’t really make things easy for them), but I also find it liberating.
Reply
Jenna Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 7:41 am
You know what? You’re right. I don’t take credit for the ways he is advances (gross motor skills) so shy should I have to bear the brunt of the responsibility for why he is delayed? I’ve never thought about it this way.
Reply
LPC Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 1:04 pm
Exactly. Alternatively, you have some responsibility for both aspects of P., and you support him in his progression on all fronts. But NO UNDUE MOM SHAME:).
Reply
Katy Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 5:46 pm
Exactly. Completely. Ditto.
Reply
October 11th, 2011 on 1:08 am
Just a wee story for you - The lady across the road from my Mum and Dad had a wee grandson the same age as me. He had two older sisters and didn’t talk until he was four years old.
His first words? “Sh*t Grandma, look out for the letterbox!”
Don’t beat yourself up, he’ll (and you) will be fine!
Reply
October 11th, 2011 on 1:08 am
I know it’s different, but I was significantly delayed in speaking because I couldn’t hear (thank you, constant ear infections and a twice-burst eardrum) and I caught up very quickly despite the delay. I know my parents felt guilty that they didn’t notice I was practically deaf for so long. It’s the way of things for parents to feel guilty when something happens to their children that’s less than ideal. My sister tries to fault herself for her son’s seizures. My brother feels guilty when his son gets constant ear infections (that sounds familiar). Heaven forbid I pass any of my genetic illnesses on to any children I have; I couldn’t imagine. In short, I seriously doubt this is your “fault” in anyway, but your feelings are natural. I do recommend therapy as soon as possible; it’s done great things for my nephew and for my friend’s son who was delayed in speech and eating solids. My nephew is still nonverbal, but he has profound problems T1 clearly doesn’t have, and speech therapy has still helped in many ways. It’s called early intervention for a reason.
Reply
Mandy Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 1:37 am
My best friend had the exact same issue growing up with multiple ear infections and burst eardrums and also needed speech therapy starting around 4-5 I think. I wonder how common that is?
Reply
October 11th, 2011 on 1:32 am
I’ve been reading your blog for awhile, and just wanted to offer you some virtual hugs. Speech delays are precisely that: delays. Children do catch up; you have not ruined him. Also, as others have mentioned, speech delays are more common among children who are raised in bilingual households. Again, though, these are just delays; children catch up, and once they do they have the benefit of knowing two languages. You might be interested in this link and some of the other resources mentioned: http://www.lsadc.org/info/ling-faqs-biling_child.cfm
This said, I really would encourage you to find a way to provide him with the services that the therapists recommended, as this can only help him to catch up more quickly. It must be frustrating for him (and you) to not be able to communicate what he needs and wants, especially as he gets older and is exploring the world more and more. You mentioned above that sometimes you are frustrated in not knowing the best way to play with him. Therapists will typically give you “homework” - games to play to help with language development. Don’t be afraid to ask! These are people who are trained to answer these very types of questions. Parents who care about their children - as you so obviously do - are the very best types of parents to work with.
Be strong and give T1 and big hug. You can do it!
Reply
October 11th, 2011 on 1:32 am
My two oldest sisters talked early, did everything early, and then my brother came along and my mom thought something was seriously wrong with him! He spoke late (among other things) and he’s the most intelligent out of all 5 of us (the one that spoke the earliest did the worst in school, maybe she was too busy talking? lol).
You cannot be to blame, just like parents of early talkers aren’t responsible. I have an old neighbor that drank a lot of alcohol throughout her pregnancies, and her son is 3 and can’t talk, and they won’t get him therapy or teach him to sign because they’ve decided he’s just being lazy and if he wanted to speak, he would. I feel sad for him, because he is being neglected in more ways than one. I have a few friends here whose little girls hardly speak or make any sounds (they are the second children, and their older siblings were early talkers), and their docs aren’t that worried about it and neither are the parents. You’ll do what you think is best for T1, and if you make mistakes, you’ll learn from them and do better next time (or maybe make it again, being a mom is hard!). I don’t think that talking constantly to a child, naming objects, whatever, can make too much difference in a kids language abilities when he has normal, loving parents. Good luck with this new little endeavor!
Reply
October 11th, 2011 on 1:35 am
Don’t beat yourself up. I think the most important thing to remember is that normal is just an average. There are kids that fall on both sides of that, and being delayed has nothing to do with you not devoting your every second to giving T1 attention.
The younger boy I used to nanny, had issues with speech delay as well. When I started watching him he was 18 months & only said “please”, “dog”, “mama” & “dada”, “yes” & “no” on a regular basis. A couple of other words were used much less frequently. Within about 9 months he was talking like crazy, something must have clicked and you couldn’t even tell that he had been behind before. However, if the therapists think that he should have speech therapy now (versus wait a year), I personally wouldn’t wait.
Reply
October 11th, 2011 on 2:52 am
First, I will never understand why some people feel the need to kick someone when they’re already down. When did that ever do any good?
Second, we went/are going through a very similar thing with our firstborn and made the decision to discontinue speech therapy. Before all you haters come out to berate me let me say it was not a decision we took lightly. But it was the right one for us. Because frankly, therapy isn’t the best decision in EVERY case. If you’d like all the details feel free to email me Jenna. I know you will make the right decision for T1. You are his mom and know him better than anyone so go with your gut. (aka the Spirit for us LDS).
Thirdly, we tend to forget that humans are extremely complex creatures. It’s easy to say that there is something wrong with your child when he doesn’t keep the same pace as other kids. When it could be just as possible that he simply doesn’t have anything to say.
So like I said before, go with your gut. Look into his eyes. And pray. You will get your answer and know the right thing to do.
Reply
October 11th, 2011 on 4:15 am
Hi jenna
I think things will just turn out fine. My aunt’s daughter is 22 months now and she doesnt speak much too.she says mamma / papa , responds to questions like where is mamma, where is papa, where is (insert her name)etc. by pointing in the right direction. She also points out her hair,teeth,nose..i think thats about it…not more..we are not that worried…i think some kids just take more time.:)
Reply
October 11th, 2011 on 5:28 am
Guilt is normal, but the reason he is experiencing delays is irrelevant (it could be environment, but it could be genetic). Just focus on what you can do from here. I did study language development during my degree studies for my sign language degree, and I have a few suggestions for you.
With the sign language… try incorporating fun signs. He can tell you that he’s hungry or wants to leave… and has been able to tell you that since he was born (by crying!). He didn’t need another way to tell you that. Try incorporating a few signs like “ball”… or other things that he finds interesting (we used light, dog, and flower because there was a flower on baby G’s mobile). He has to realize that the signs aren’t just arbitrary for them to be useful for him before he will be motivated to use them.
For anything to do with language - the sooner, the better. I understand the importance of staying out of debt and being fiscally responsible, but language delays only get worse over time, and the longer you wait, the harder it is to fix.
You are great parents, which is easily evident, so while it is normal to feel guilty - don’t linger on it. T1 needs you to be positive and present. Good luck!
Reply
Senora H-B Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 7:44 am
Jessica, I’m filing this away for my future children. What a fun way to encourage communication! Every kid I have ever known loves to turn on lights and fans. I love it!!
Reply
October 11th, 2011 on 6:22 am
I hope you’re not letting this person bother you. My friend went through this exact same thing with her son, at about the same age,too. She is a special education teacher and did nothing but interact with her son in both educational and social ways. It didn’t make a difference. But, after therapy she found new and different ways to interact with him that helped. The tantrums went away, and they found ways to communicate that satisfied her son.
We don’t know the amount that you interact with T1 - none of us. We get a small glimpse into your life. I have no doubts that you are just as great a parent as my friend, and that you will have great success with this therapy. Please don’t let mommy guilt get you down - there is NOTHING that could have changed the outcome of T1′s development.
It sounds like you’re not letting the ignorant comments get you down - try to stay strong
Reply
October 11th, 2011 on 6:32 am
Congrats on getting your son the therapy he needs, but I think it’s kind of sad that you seem to view “talking incessantly” and “using a sing song voice” as an example of an overobsessed parent. Very small children need that kind of constant interaction and one-on-one time to develop. With that said, I hope the therapy works and the therapists can help you figure out new ways to play and interact with your son.
Reply
phruphru Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 9:14 am
Those phrases also took me aback in Jenna’s post but I think Jenna wrote this while still very much in the moment. Heck, she hadn’t even talked to her mom yet.
Reply
October 11th, 2011 on 7:30 am
Jenna, I understand what it is to have a child delayed. You know that. While Grant having Down syndrome isn’t my fault, I’m always racked with thoughts that I can be doing more. And you know what? I could. There are parents of kids with DS that are constantly going from one apppointment to another - one workshop to another - one something to another. But that constant occupation of our schedule never appealed to me.
Mind you, I definately take him to my fair share of appointments. At least double or triple what parents of typical children will ever do - Medical specialists and therapy. Speech therapy is something I’ve really pushed for with him because him being able to speak understandably is very important to me, so of anything I do for him, that is the main priority. Grant is also very behind in speech, even more than your average child with DS. I always wonder what other more things (non-therapy related) I can do for him. It’s normal to wonder what more you could have done. But I also have to weigh all that Grant requires against normal family life which is ALSO very important to me. If we spent the majority of our lives in the car shuttling from one thing to another I think Grant (and his parents) would lose out on that significant and beautiful ritual of just normal life. Learning about the world and experiencing it through our time together doing regular tasks.
The fact is: some kids take longer to do things. What percentage of the cause is parents, environment, and ‘that’s just how he was born’ is not for any of us on the internet to say. You may even wonder and it’s your life! So certainly, none of us can tie it to a specific reason. I’ve told you before, Grant’s previous speech therapist told me that other than kids with actual developmental disablities (like Down syndrome), the vast majority of her typical developing clients were *first-born boys*. According to her, boys take a bit longer and if they don’t have siblings or peer they are around, it may take them a bit longer. But obviously this all gets worked out eventually or we’d see millions of men walking around without speech skills!
Even IF all this was YOUR fault, now is the time to work with what you have, get him the help you feel is necessary, and just progress with your life knowing that - - - he’s the big key - - - as much as parents like to think THEY are the primary and only reason their child fails/succeeds, they really can’t take all the blame/adulation. It’s much more complicated than that.
So, do what you feel is best. It sounds like speech therapy would not hurt at all and may give you good tools for working with him - and it may not be a long term thing anyway. BUT, I’m sure discussing it with your husband and pray you’ll come to the right conclusion for your son.
Also, consider having more formal outings with lots of friends T1′s age - peer speech is very helpful for child learning to communicate. Kyle having a brother like Grant hasn’t had the peer speech that he would otherwise have and I put him in a daycare most days a week for about 3 weeks (while we were moving into our new house here in OH - very convienent for setting up house as well!) and is speech improved dramatically. I’m not saying you need to send him to daycare, but some kind of set times during the week where he can be around other talkers (which may be playing with kids about 2 years or older) can help and influence as well.
Good luck! Like that Old Testament scripture says “There be more for us {you} than against us {you}” {on this blog!}
Reply
Jenna Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 7:53 am
So many good things about this comment. First you reminded me of all the things I’ve read which basically conclude that shuttling our kids around (basically doing *everything* for them) doesn’t pay off in the end like you would think it would.
Second, it was nice to be reminded that there are reasons both of us need him to do the therapy. He needs to talk, and I need him to talk as well.
Also you moved! I hope it went well
Reply
October 11th, 2011 on 7:37 am
I’m not a parent (except to two dogs and no one expects them to talk) so I don’t have any personal experience with this. I just wanted to say that I’m thinking of you and your family, wishing all three of you the best. Also, perhaps you were joking with your last sentence about getting some therapy of your own, but I wouldn’t hesitate to do just that if you are still feeling plagued with guilt.
Reply
October 11th, 2011 on 7:37 am
Your comments seem a little less hateful than the previous commentor and you seem to come from a place of geniuine concern, but the toys issue and the books issue isn’t something to bring up. Kids these days have WAY too many toys. Studies have shown that fewer toys can actually be more developmentally helpful than more because kids often have to use their minds to invent more ways to use that item. I’ve always avoided having large numbers of toys lying around - it’s costly, over-stimulating and kids don’t ever learn to use their imagination if the second they get sick of something they can turn to ther 300 toys in their playroom to play with (and YES, it’s annoying as all heck to put that stuff away when parents can avoid it by cutting back).
Also, I have a blog (not nearly as big or wide read as Jenna’s of course) and come to think of it, I probably have very few pictures of my kids reading. Hm. That must mean that I don’t have books or encourage them to read with me ever, because if the BLOG doesn’t show it, it doesn’t happen, right? If that’s true, Jenna must never shower because I’ve never seen a post with her actually taking a shower.
Reply
Katy Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 7:40 am
Okay, this was in repsonse to a comment that I had to set straight! But…now it’s gone. Oh well, I’ll leave up my reply anyway!
Reply
Senora H-B Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 7:47 am
Good. Because I think it’s a great comment! I’m also filing this away for my future children. We all have too much junk in our lives. I mean, think about kids a hundred years ago. They couldn’t have had a bajillion toys to play with - they were creative with what they found around them. Too bad nothing good ever came from any of them….waaaaiiiit…..
Reply
Jessica Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 7:49 am
I suspect it was my original comment, which was unsurprisingly deleted. Here’s my stance on the books and toys: I’m a parent of a 2 year old. I KNOW how annoying it is to have toys/books everywhere, especially if you’re someone who likes it neat. But these are things they need. I’m not saying T1 or any child needs a MOUNTAIN of toys. But I think we can agree more than five is not unreasonable, especially at 18 months. Wooden puzzles with the big blocky puzzle pieces- teaches them animals (or whatever the puzzle pieces are shaped like) and how to put the pieces in the right space. Flash cards, so they can learn the object on the card. Just simple things that kids NEED to learn!
I’m sure a lot of parents don’t put pictures of their kids doing things on their blogs, and that doesn’t mean the kids don’t do those things. But Jenna is different in that she does these VERY in-depth Day in the Life posts, and I challenge you to find one in which any significant portion of time was spent interacting or doing anything with T1. There’s a VERY obvious correlation here between the amount/quality of time she and TH spend with him and the fact that he’s delayed. This is not the cause of every delayed child, but it’s pretty undeniable in this case. She’s said TH doesn’t like interacting with him much, and her own insight into her life proves she’s usually too busy to bother as well. Jenna’s comments on this post make it pretty clear that she looks down upon people who “incessantly” talk to their children or use “sing songy” voices and count everything. THIS is what invested and involved parents do. Sorry if it makes Jenna feel stupid, but this is part of RAISING a child.
And I stand by my comment that it’s ridiculous for parents who sent themselves on an Italian vacation and went to a $400 dinner and ordered the new iPhone now find it hard to justify spending the money on therapy for their child. The mind truly boggles. I can’t imagine most parents would disagree with me on that.
Reply
Jenna Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 7:57 am
You need to get a life and step memorizing every detail and overanalyzing mine. This is sad. Try yoga. Or hiking. Or even reading some books. It will do more good.
Reply
Jessica Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 8:01 am
Typical blogger response. “I want you to come here and read my posts for traffic, but don’t you dare remember any of it to bring up later.” I remember these things because they stuck out as being strange. You are unwilling to take a look at how you could do ANYTHING differently to benefit your son, and that is sad. Try taking people’s advice and find a way to get him his therapy, “it will do more good” than battling comments on your blog.
Reply
Jenna Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 8:22 am
No, you remember these things because you are one of those despicable low-lifes that troll GOMI. You guys know all the same data points and talk about them over and over. Because you apparently have nothing better to do.
I, on the other hand, am living my life, making connections, and generally feeling happy. Until I come into contact with people like you, that is.
I’ve decided to think of you the same way I think about the woman on Catfish. As someone to be pitied.
Reply
MrsW Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 2:34 pm
so just to be that annoying person with a tangentially related nearly non sequitur… probably most long-time readers are gonna remember things like that. I remember lots of things like that and I don’t think I’m obsessive about you. I just have a good memory. I presume you must have some sort of behind the scenes info that allows you to pin this particular comment on trolls, and not just an observant reader?
I know I can’t begin to imagine the stress that taking crap from haters is like, but I have to say I miss the classy Jenna response to trolls.
Reply
Nicole Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 4:14 pm
Ditto. Jenna - Sorry about the bad news and haters. However, I am a long time reader and I remember these things about you too. I hope that doesn’t make me a troll, someone without a life, sad, pathetic, dispeicable low life etc. You do emphasize certain thing a lot - like the amount of toys, etc. Keep it classy and stop name calling your loyal readers!
Reply
Lea Reply:
October 12th, 2011 at 2:11 pm
I have to say-I am a TW blog reader and once I accidentally stumbled upon the site Jenna is referring to above. It is full of hatred-it appears that the commenters there spend a lot of time taking and trading scrupulous notes about blog minutiae in order to talk crap about various bloggers. So I see what she is talking about. It’s a disturbing place.
Anyway, enough about that. Jenna, you are a great mom. I admire your parenting style. Everyone runs into challenges-it’s how you work through them that counts!
Reply
LPC Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 1:17 pm
I wouldn’t presume to say how others ought to spend their money. I do however concur that kids are well-served by allowing the stuff to proliferate. That’s how they play, but fiddling with stuff small enough and at their level. See what P. does in that video, with the shampoo bottles. That’s play. I believe in tidying up, not putting it all away.
Reply
Katy Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 8:01 am
Jenna - - please feel free to delete all this if choose, since it was in relation to a comment you wished not on your blog - since of course it’s your blog! I won’t mind!
To address the in-depth Day in the Life that you gather the majority of your information, yes, her posts are in depth. And again, if I did an in-depth view of my day on any random day several days a year, you might see me not read to my child once. But then the next day, the day not seen on the blog, I’ll read 20 books. Maybe I’m not a very super consistent person-maybe we had too many appoinments that day- maybe WHATEVER. The point is - even with an in depth look at *three* days of an entire year, you still may not see me doing the things I typically do on many other days of the year. Don’t hold that against anyone.
Reply
October 11th, 2011 on 7:38 am
my son Gus has the EX7ACT same delays that you described with T1. Here is where I get to tell you how AMAZING God is. 4 months ago, Gus tested with Autism and would prefer to play alone and tested at a 0-3 month level when he was 14 months old. I cried. a lot. a whole lot. Within 4 months he is a totally different child. He is super playful and interactive, I had a ton of guilt. After all of that we were told he has a hearing loss and would need hearing aids for the rest of his life. We went to get them yesterday and were told a miracle took place and his hearing was totally restored.
T1 has a great mom who loves him. Some kids just need extra help, it is so great that you can get that!! In your home no less!! The mom guilt will always be there in some form or another, have grace for yourself. Just keep working with him and talking to him and it will be ok. love
Reply
October 11th, 2011 on 7:41 am
People have told me that once you have your second child, you learn just how much of the development of your child depends ON THE CHILD, not on your parenting skills. You are a vital, irreplaceable influence on your son’s life — but you cannot either make him or break him (beyond repair). He makes himself.
That being said, I think therapy is a GREAT option to pursue, and I concur with all of the other commenters on trying to work through the school district. Another option might be, as you’re in a college town, seeing if there are speech pathology grad students who need some experience as a stop-gap measure before you get back on company insurance (cause oh man student insurance sucks… we only elected for MrW because it is just sooooo expensive). I’ve got a family friend who got her degree in speech pathology at North Park and she’s very good.
Reply
October 11th, 2011 on 7:48 am
I am an early intervention speech pathologist and I am telling you that it is not your fault! I see children who have been in such language rich environments and they are still delayed and some children who do not have much social interaction and are not delayed. There is currently not an answer to why some children are delayed! While there is a chance that T1 will catch up on his own, it wouldn’t be something I would want to gamble on. Spend about 6 months on therapy and see what progress he makes! A great thing about having them come to your home is that you will be able to implement everything that they are doing. Being delayed in speech does not he will not be on track with his peers during school, he just needs a little boost
Also, from my experience, he will LOVE the therapists coming over to play with him!!!
Reply
October 11th, 2011 on 7:54 am
Oh, Jenna, I’m so sorry there are so many nasty commenters out there. I mean, of course you could have done things differently, more, better, whatever. We *ALL* could have. But we have absolutely zero evidence that those things might have had any kind of effect. What would be the purpose of obsessing on having done things differently (not that I don’t spend hours doing just that…).
The point is, you’re doing exactly what you should be now. You’ve found a problem, you’re tackling it, and you will deal with it (with grace and enthusiasm, I’m sure). You are strong. You are an excellent mother. You have done your research and your work. T1 is an individual. He’s bright, he’s social, he’s (freaking) adorable.
I second (third?) the commenters who have suggested not delaying therapy. The way to do it will open for you and TH. I know it will. You all are in my thoughts and prayers today.
Reply
October 11th, 2011 on 7:54 am
Hugs, my friend!
Please don’t stress yourself out too much! You are taking all of the right steps. P is FINE. & so stinkin’ cute!!
Reply
Jenna Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 8:02 am
He is pretty cute. I keep thinking of that moment yesterday when he leaned in on his high chair like he wanted to join our conversation, haha.
Reply
LPC Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 1:18 pm
He’s super cute.
Reply
October 11th, 2011 on 8:17 am
Jenna, you’ve gotten a lot of advice so I will just point you in the direction of Amalah if case you don’t already read her. Her oldest son had some developmental delays and she discusses them candidly. She has three children so I think you’ll find her thoughts on deciding to have more children when your oldest needs special attention helpful. She also learned a lot from her son’s therapy. Like you, she always talked to her son but b/c he had different needs than other children, she had to learn HOW to talk to him. Therapy can only help…
http://www.amalah.com/ (she curses a little)
Reply
October 11th, 2011 on 8:19 am
Ugh, this is so tough. I feel for you, and I hope you aren’t beating yourself up. I think that it is awesome that you and TH are being proactive about this and seeking some professional advice about T1′s development, but I don’t think you have anything to feel guilty about. As many people above said, kids develop at really different paces. That said, it is definitely good to take action NOW, while these small delays are manageable and before they become larger issues that will take more time/effort/money. Because of that, I would recommend trying as hard as possible to find room in your family’s budget for the therapy now. But also, don’t beat yourself up about this. You are doing a great job- just keep on keepin’ on. If the therapists had suggestions for things you can do with T1 that will help, great, definitely take their advice, but don’t feel a lot of guilt if they aren’t things you were previously doing. Life is a learning process- motherhood included! Hang in there!
Reply
October 11th, 2011 on 8:31 am
I recently found your blog (don’t really remember how) and wanted to comment.
I too am an SLP, though currently staying home with our first. I’m just finding out about mommy guilt, lol…
I worked in an elemen. school with pre-k-5th grade. I will say that early intervention can work wonders. Its amazing the progress kids make. I don’t know how Chicago schools work, but where I was they didn’t enter the school system until they were three. Before that some were in an birth to three program run by the state…all states have some form of one (though not always called the same name). I don’t know if that’s who evaluated your son or not.
If you choose therapy they will work with you to teach you strategies that you can do at home..in fact, the birth to three program to me is more about supporting the parent and their role in parenting the child..but anyways.
You didn’t ruin your child! Its NOT your fault. You know your child the best, trust in that as you go forward. He seems to me to be a happy and healthy little boy who might benefit from a little help. That’s ok. I think you’ve done a great job thus far. Take some time to take it all in and make the best decision for your family — don’t let anyone rush you.
Reply
October 11th, 2011 on 8:39 am
I have 9 month-old twins, so my entire life is like some sort of childhood development study. And I’ve got to say: kids come pre-loaded with a lot of software. Before having kids, I was firmly in the environment/nurture camp. Now, I’m not so sure. They had distinctive personalities in the womb; outside it, they couldn’t be more different. Nutrition, environment, interaction: all these things matter. But genetics, brain chemistry, personality, and nature: well, these are less flexible and might matter more.
Even less than a year in, I know that motherhood is practically defined by sacrifice and guilt, with flashes of pride and happiness. But despite that, kids are who they are. They are malleable, but not infinitely so.
We, your readers, know very little about your life. But the flashes that we get reveal that you’re a happy, laid back, loving mom. Don’t let the haters get you down.
(And, with more than one kid, I can assure you that the guilt only increases exponentially with each child. I’ve spent time being actively angry with my ovaries for releasing more than one egg, thus diluting the amount of attention I can give my kids. How silly is that? In my more rational moments, I recognize it. But parenthood just isn’t rational.)
Reply
October 11th, 2011 on 8:42 am
Please don’t put off therapy. A family member’s child had very delayed speech and even with therapy barely spoke until they were four. Now with *years* of therapy the kid is finally talking. It is so beneficial.
Also, maybe playgroups or library reading circles might be helpful so he’s exposed to other kids and adults talking. If you’re interested in teaching him Polish too I know of a playgroup in the Dallas area that does that. Feel free to email me if you’re interested once you move back.
Reply
October 11th, 2011 on 8:56 am
Jenna, after reading your twitter update I was up all night wanting to reply to you and hoping you posted a blog about this. I am a psychologist and work with children with autism specifically but also developmental delays. Don’t put it off because of cost. Try to go through a school, that service should be free. There is head start and that is very helpful but as you want to do home therapy that can also be done through schools. Some insurances now cover most autism therapies and are adding speech, developmental and occupational therapies. You can do this momma. As for the school of thought that this could some how be caused by momma neglect. Sure it could if you stuck him in the closet and never spoke to him. Otherwise, even children from negligent homes generally still speak.
The idea that “my child didn’t talk until he was … insert a number and he is fine” please don’t use that as a false sense of security. Does it happen? Absolutely. Will that be your case? Who can tell! What I want you to do is gather your husband and any other help you can and dig in full force. Studies absolutely show that the earlier the intervention the better. Developmental delays with no other outlying causes can be caught up with appropriate intervention.
He will stop the tantrums as soon as he can get his point across to you.
As far as the whys, and the what ifs… don’t go there. This is not productive. I promise.
If you want to email me feel free I have other resources and ideas I could give you. Please don’t tarry. There are even things you can do at home as a lot of times getting through all the red tape to get him the therapy can take up to 6 months sometimes and that is time you can work with him.
You can do it. And yes mommy always needs cheerleaders honey.
Reply
LPC Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 1:20 pm
Best comment on the thread:).
Reply
Jenny Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 6:06 pm
This is really great advice. I couldn’t have said it better.
You are a good mother and I know this will all turn out just fine.
A side note on sign language-
We have been doing sign language with our son for quite some time now and it has been so good for him. He is able to let us know just what he means, which is huge and made tantrums go away. I was really surprised how long it took for the signs to stick though initially. Like 2-3 months. I thought “this isn’t working” and I felt silly doing them with no response back, especially in public but my husband was super consistent and sure enough 3 months in he signed his first sign with dad. After that I jumped on board and now it is just a natural part of our speech. We love the baby signing time videos (and I am not one to have him watch much tv! but he and we have learned many signs from them) Anyway, just my two cents on doing signing. The most helpful ones for me are ones that really communicate a need like “help” or “hurt”. His favorites are fun ones like “ball” or “dog”
Reply
Rachel Reply:
October 12th, 2011 at 6:09 am
I just wanted to point out as one of the people who commented about having a later talker who ended up fine.
I was just trying to give a little perspective not a false sense of security. I was extremely concerned and so I asked about it. My pediatrician (who is not the “let it be” type) said a lot of kids get put into speech therapy that don’t need it which is a waste of time and money. He suggested really observing your child and looking at learning in a bigger picture than just parts of the whole. If they are making significant progress in one area then another area may take a back seat (especially true with fine/gross motor skills vs. language).
I think it’s important to avoid making snap decisions just because an expert or professional is telling you something is wrong with you or your child. To me, it is kind of like OB’s and labor/delivery. “If you don’t do x, your child will suffer.” Obviously therapy is important and an appropriate choice for a lot of people. I just like to take a more informed approach and look at the big picture. Which is why I suggested taking some time to think about it and not make an emotional decision. A few weeks or a month is not going to do irreparable damage but it may give you some clarity in your situation.
For me, I took the month or so of distance from the experts to make some changes. We started Tot School which I just take 5-20 minutes, depending on his level of interest, a few times a day to do some learning activities that are usually end-specific but don’t have to be. Since my son loves anything involving fine/gross motor skills I just started narrating what he was doing but not in an obsessive way, just “yep, good job putting the beans in the jar, when you shake it it makes a rattle sound.” and then let him play some more. We increased our participation in play groups. And by ‘increased’ I mean we joined one. We started going to the library reading group. They have one weekly for age 0-2 and another one weekly for age 0-4. At ours they alternate books and songs with actions then do a craft which is usually coloring or stickers or something. My son also turned 18 months and started going to nursery at church.
With all of those changes which took up maybe an extra few hours a week total, we saw a huge improvement. Otherwise, I would have done therapy.
So I just wanted to point out that sometimes waiting isn’t the same thing as doing nothing.
Reply
Rachel Reply:
October 12th, 2011 at 6:36 am
Although, I know a lot of people think if it certainly can’t hurt and could only help why not just do it? I don’t find much wrong with that in a situation like this.
Reply
October 11th, 2011 on 9:06 am
No advice or words of wisdom, just passing along an article from yesterday’s NYTimes that seems pertinent (about bilingual learning in babies) and may be of some interest: http://www.nytimes.com/2011/10/11/health/views/11klass.html?_r=1
Reply
October 11th, 2011 on 9:07 am
Like I said on Twitter, my mom is a speech therapist and this is VERY common! I agree with Kate that therapy shouldn’t be put off though, because it’s very important for him to have it in order to gain more verbal skills. Good luck though - please don’t think you’re a failure. Your true readers and friends DON’T think that!
Reply
October 11th, 2011 on 9:17 am
Hi Jenna. I just want to say that I am glad you had T1 tested and that you now know what is going on with him and what needs to happen to get him caught up. I have a very close family member who has a developmentally delayed child. This child couldn’t even say Mama or Dada at 2. He has had very intensive therapy and at age 3 he can say just about any word he hears, string together sentences, count to 30, and spell. His delay had nothing to do with interaction…it was just a genetic “birth defect”. Please don’t blame yourself for this.
However, please please please do not delay his therapy for any reason. The sooner you start, the sooner T1 will be caught up. Just imagine how hard this is for him. He knows exactly what he wants to tell you but he doesn’t know how. Right now, you and TH are the only people that have the ability to give him what he needs and what he needs right now is therapy.
Internet hugs for you. I know how hard this must be for you.
Oh and ignore the haters. People suck.
Reply
October 11th, 2011 on 9:21 am
It’s harder said then done but you shouldn’t feel guilty for this. Speech problems happen. Learning disabilities happen. All types of things happen. And quite often, it’s nobodies fault.
In my family there were me and 3 siblings. We all had to take speech. Which would make you wonder if it was because of the way my parents spoke or treated us. But the reason I don’t believe this is that there was a difference between genders. My sister and I took speech for a very long time and have experienced problems learning in specific areas. My brothers only took speech for a few years and then were done for good. I just don’t believe that this happened because my parent’s gave more attention to my brothers or something. I am much more willing to believe this occurred because of genetics or some other unknown (to me) reason. Even now I have problems. I still stumbled on my words a lot, my vocabulary is awful, and learning a new language has been nearly impossible. But I think it’s just the way my brain is wired, not because my parents let me watch too much t.v. or didn’t show me enough attention or didn’t speak clearly to me.
The point is that you shouldn’t feel guilty. He will be just fine if he gets the help he needs. He might not be perfect or even problem free in the learning area later in his life, but being perfect isn’t everything.
Reply
October 11th, 2011 on 9:27 am
Don’t beat yourself up about this (I know that’s easier said than done). My husband didn’t speak until he was about 2 1/2 and his mother was a Head Start teacher specializing in speech therapy. She did everything “by the book” and he just chose to develop that skill a little later. He did work with additional speech therapists though elementary school but he grew up to be a very intelligent man.
As to delaying therapy, ultimately it’s your decision, I know if I were in your place I’d want to start right away though. I agree with some of the previous posts. I’d talk to the counselors you’ve already seen and see if there are any more affordable options or even a student clinic you could take him to until your insurance situation changes.
Best wishes. I’m sure this is a very emotional time for your little family but the good news is this sounds like it is a “fixable” issue.
Reply
October 11th, 2011 on 9:43 am
Please do not blame your self. I may not be a mother, but I know that blaming ones self is never good. Everyone develops at different ages/stages. Just keep that in mind. You’ve made the first step to get him checked and now you know what needs to be done. Check your options, obviously speech therapy is free once he’s in school, but that’s a long way too wait. Good luck with everything.
Reply
October 11th, 2011 on 9:48 am
My youngest niece is four and she didn’t ‘really’ start to talking until she was around 3. There were maybe 10 words she’d say, and a whole lot of jabber. But she didn’t even start trying to communicate until she was 2 or so. She does go to a community ed speech program which has helped a lot, but she only started that after she started preschool at 3.
She talks like crazy now but we still don’t understand all of it. She’s getting better though, and quickly. I think it was just a matter of waiting for her to be ready. No amount of play/talk/signaling/therapy convinced her to start talking until she was ready. As far as her development, she’s smarter than any of us realize. The other day she linked together something that we’d done 4 month earlier. Once we figured out what she was saying we realized she’s more aware than any of us thought.
Reply
October 11th, 2011 on 9:57 am
Just out of interest are you raising T1 to be bilingual? My husband is French, and she goes to a French daycare here in Canada but I am English. My husband only talks to her in French, and she is schooled in French (she will be 2 in a month) but I use only English. They say children that are exposed to two languages from the get-go actually start speaking later as there is so much more to process. M daughter says lots of words, but no sentences yet and sometimes we have trouble knowing if she is speaking in one language or the other. To echo everyone else, do not feel guilty! Children do develop at a different pace. Keep your head up and know you’re a great Mom
Reply
October 11th, 2011 on 10:08 am
Please don’t beat yourself up about this. Despite current conventional wisdom, every child still does develop differently - and it’s rarely a linear trajectory.
My DH’s oldest brother didn’t really speak until he was two… and then he had a pretty bad stutter. My MIL just sort of waited it out, though, and now he’s an English teacher and one of the most articulate men I know. I’m sure he would have been labeled as “delayed” if he was a little kid today.
I find it especially encouraging that P likes to engage with other kids - that tells me it’s not something more serious like autism-spectrum stuff. Therapy will likely be a help, but I’ve known a couple of kiddos P’s age who kind of dug in their heels with speech therapists and refused to talk with them, so definitely see if it’s a good fit for him.
He’s a cutie and you’re doing a great job with him.
Reply
October 11th, 2011 on 10:18 am
Don’t let the trolls get you down. You know you are a good Mom!
Reply
October 11th, 2011 on 11:10 am
I’m not reading through all the comments so I’m sure this has been said before, but Jenna, you are doing NOTHING wrong. Every kid is different, you know? Look how early he started walking! And he’s so bright. This speech stuff will fall into place eventually, and I bet the therapy helps get him right on track. Some kids just need a boost.
My sister did speech therapy early on in school and now she’s 22 and never shuts up
Big hugs to you and TH — I think you need one now, because all we ever want for our kids is for them to be healthy and happy, but we can’t help wanting them to be “perfect” as well. There’s a lot of people thinking of you right now, and I look forward to an update post in the future with a video of T1 talking away. xoxoxoxo
Reply
October 11th, 2011 on 11:16 am
As mothers each of us can say we should have done something better. Remember: You are the best mother for YOUR child.
Check to see if your state has a “Early Intervention Program,” Utah has one. We were in the program from 3 months (my daughter was born deaf) to 5 years. It is a free program for any child who is having difficulty intellectual, physically, or both. They provided therapy to us on how we should teach language,useful techniques, to having speech therapy once a week. The great thing is that you have time on your side. It’s all about early intervention… Children form language until 5 and then learn enunciating until much later. You’ve got several years. My daughter made HUGE strides and now she is in first grade doing grade level work.
Never underestimate your child. With love and support (and prayer) they can do AMAZING things. From what I can read and see you are giving him that. All I can say is keep strong and carry on!
Reply
Alison Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 11:25 am
I believe this is the link for Illinois.
http://www.eiclearinghouse.org/getting-started.html
Reply
October 11th, 2011 on 11:30 am
My husband didn’t speak at all until he was 3. Then he busted out with “Mom I’d like some green beans please,” and he eventually went to MIT. I’m betting P will be just fine.
Reply
Katie Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 6:50 pm
Comments like this are sweet, but not helpful. That’s great it worked out for your husband. Many other children, however, ewho don’t speak at all until they’re three experience speech delays with lasting effects. Early interventions are key! I’m sure T1 will be fine, too, but interventions should be sought out.
Reply
October 11th, 2011 on 11:31 am
Sorry if I repeat anything from above, but that is a LOT of comments to try to read through!
We had a very similar experience.
Our daughter (now 22 months) was not talking much at 12 or 15 months, but then at 18 months the pediatrician was concerned and sent us to a speech therapist for an evaluation. She tested very low and was diagnosed with verbal Apraxia. Our insurance approved therapy, which we felt very grateful for, since i have heard so many others are not so lucky. But we still have to pay a $20 copay for every single session (right now it’s once a week, but soon switching to twice a week. oy).
Our daughter has progressed really well, and even though it is definitely a financial burden, I think the earlier the better for an intervention. Let me know if you have any questions about verbal Apraxia!
Reply
October 11th, 2011 on 11:36 am
one more thing. while I totally understand the sentiment and attempt to reassure, I have found from experience that most people will say “oh, so-and-so didn’t talk until they were 3 and no problem now.” or something to that effect. I have learned, however, that some speech disorders don’t just resolve on their own, and some kids NEED some help like therapy, and it’s ok. People sometimes think that therapy makes it some horrible tragedy, and it’s better to just say “he’ll be fine.” Well, he will be fine, but sometimes therapy is the only way to get there.
Reply
October 11th, 2011 on 11:56 am
My little brother had to go to a speech therapist when he was 4 or 5 years old until he was almost 10. He had had issues with tongue and other mouth muscle control and when he was 4 had his tonsils removed because the doctors thought they were too large for him and making speech difficult. I’m not much older than him, so I don’t remember a lot of specifics, but I do remember that he had difficulty learning to speak after that. I don’t remember if he could talk before the surgery very well or not.
I guess I’m trying to say that there are reasons that have absolutely nothing to do with how you parent that could cause these development delays. And that the delays may prevail as something positive in the end! My brother had to deal with delays throughout his education, in part because of this, but now has an incredible support system of friends and can NOT stop talking (making up for lost time?)! He also has a far greater amount of discipline than I could ever begin to claim. He’s excelled in marching in a drum corp for 7 years, leaving home every summer, all summer long.
Don’t worry too much about why this is happening, just trust that T1 will end up better for it!
Reply
October 11th, 2011 on 12:14 pm
Jenna, please do what you can to get your son the therapy he needs. My sister and my best friend’s brother are the same age and both had a similar problem with speech. My parents got speech therapy for my sister and while she spoke with a bit of an impediment until she was about 7, after that you’d never know there had ever been an issue with her speech.
My best friend’s parents decided to wait it out. D was born in late December so they held him back a year to let him mature a bit and hopefully work the speech issue out. He ended up repeating grade one because he still couldn’t speak well enough to communicate. The kids picked on him and he was frustrated. When he was 7, part way through grade one the first time, they finally got him into speech therapy. It took until he was 10 or 11 before he caught up. He’s probably an extreme case, but the therapists all suggested that if they’d intervened at 3/4 (as my parents did with my sister) he probably wouldn’t have been held back. He likely would have still started school a year late due to maturity issues, but those could have been tied to speech too.
He’s a normal, well adjusting 27 year old today, but he remembers what it was like not being able to communicate. My sister remember going to speech therapy, but she remembers it as games and getting to talk to someone with out her three siblings trying to interrupt.
Good luck!
Reply
October 11th, 2011 on 12:19 pm
First of all, don’t feel guilty! I’m already getting mommy guilt just reading these replies and my kid isn’t here yet!
I did see my in-laws go through something similar with my youngest sister-in-law, now 7, a few years ago. She was diagnosed on the Autism Spectrum (Autism diagnosis is a very complicated and disputed area). She didn’t like interacting with her family, wanted to be alone, spent hours on the computer, didn’t talk much, and generally wasn’t interested in emotional connection.
My in-laws got her tested and were able to put her into a local elementary school program (the rest of my in-laws were in Catholic school) for free. It did WONDERS for her. My MIL also worked with her incessantly on a daily basis-basically got in her face and forced her to interact until she would start doing it on her own.
Now she is SO MUCH BETTER! She was re-diagnosed and does not fall on the spectrum anymore! She is in a normal class at the Catholic school and she is like a normal little girl. Before, she wouldn’t acknowledge my presence. Now, she comes up and hugs me! She is still a little behind emotionally, but she is proof therapy works. It’s scary to think where should would be right now if the issue had been ignored. It’s worth noting that she is a VERY smart little girl-she was reading aloud at 2 and is incredibly intelligent.
T1 is obviously not on this level at all, but like other posters, I’d encourage you to do the same 2 things:
-Don’t delay therapy
-Seek out what programs are available via the school system or non-for-profits
Good luck!
Reply
October 11th, 2011 on 12:50 pm
Unless the therapists told you that you are the direct cause or contributing factor to your son’s delays, you shouldn’t feel guilty.
But people are always looking for reasons WHY something happens. Sometimes, things just ARE. And the sooner we all realize this, we can move on and work on the situation.
My advice: Take this and run with it. Do all you can to provide your son with the best life he can and realize that sometimes things just ARE. Knowing that is empowering because it provides the opportunity to just get up a do. We can all spend hours debating on why something is but the truth is…it just is.
Digest it, deal with it, do something.
Reply
Jenna Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 1:03 pm
Clap clap clap! This was a great comment. Digest it, deal with it, do something. I can mange this.
Reply
KariC Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 3:15 pm
Love this! So, so true!!
Reply
Rachel Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 4:11 pm
Agreed! Think of it this way - your son will be getting extra help that could eventually put him ahead of his peers, and will improve his future. There’s no reason to be ashamed - consider yourself lucky that you live in a place where there are programs designed to better his life, and at such a (relatively) small cost! I was in speech therapy through public school from Kindergarten through 2nd grade, and my mom always said that it helped me in other areas of my life as well, like social skills, confidence, manners, etc.
Reply
October 11th, 2011 on 1:16 pm
Jenna,
I hope you are able to ignore the negative comments. You in no way ruined T1. I worked at a daycare for about 2 years, and have a degree in psychology. Every child is different!! T1′s developing at the his own pace. That being said, therapy can only help improve his speech.
Some things you can do to help foster speech development; narrating what you’re doing, asking (and answering) open-ended and close-ended questions (What are you doing? Are you jumping?), and singing “toddler” songs ( The Isty Bitsy Spider, The wheels on the bus, It’s Raining-It’s Pouring, Etc.)
While I’m sure you re currently focusing on his delay in speech- I want to remind you to focus on how much he has acheived in other developmental areas. From the video, I can tell you he has great gross motor skills for an 18-month old. Maybe he is also great at fine motor and/or coordination. You said he’s very social and that’s terrific. Sometimes in life we focus so much on what we don’t have or what’s lacking in our lives and forget to focus on what we do have!
T1 is lucky to have a mother who puts so much consideration and thought into how she parents.
Reply
October 11th, 2011 on 1:37 pm
Reading about how informed you were about giving child birth makes me think that you will be very informed about how to best help your child.
Reply
October 11th, 2011 on 3:23 pm
Whew, what a post to discover after a few days of not reading! I haven’t read through all the other comments but agree with everyone that it’s DEFINITELY not your fault. Do do the therapy as soon as you can manage it, the sooner you start the easier it can be to “catch up”.
Make sure you take care of yourself and TH too in this stressful time.
Reply
October 11th, 2011 on 4:10 pm
No guilt, Jenna! A good friend of mine went through this with her second child (her first boy). I’m not sure what they told you (or how accurate my recollection is of some conversations with my friend), but apparently this is much more common with boys — and after a year or so of weekly therapy, her son is thriving and all caught up. He’ll be okay, and you are a magnificent mother!
Reply
October 11th, 2011 on 5:47 pm
Have you read Amalah at all? I think the story of getting help for Noah and the progress he has made is the best argument for getting early intervention in developmental delays. http://www.amalah.com/amalah/speech_delays/ Yes, therapy is expensive, especially when insurance won’t pay for it, but when you decide to have children you know there are expenses involved and IMHO I feel I’d do all I could to get my children in the best possible position.
Reply
Alice Reply:
October 11th, 2011 at 5:51 pm
I also meant to say no guilt. The best parents and the smartest/best kids have bumps in the road. You did the first step getting him checked out.
Reply
October 11th, 2011 on 6:43 pm
Totally seconding all the helpful and supportive things that have been said.
But, also. That is one cute baby in a tub.
Reply
October 11th, 2011 on 7:23 pm
Jenna, so sorry that you are dealing with this. I have faith that you and your family will make it through this struggle and be stronger for it. There have been so many helpful comments already, but I thought I would chime in and offer another different perspective in regards to the guilt. One way to look at this might be to conclude that somehow you have caused T1′s delayed language skills, but another way to view the situation is to appreciate that you have helped him develop and adjust such a great extent. Who knows where he would be in terms of development if you weren’t such a good mom - perhaps he would be testing lower than he currently is. It is probably unrealistic to expect that you won’t feel any guilt over this, but hopefully the guilt stays at a manageable level. I have a feeling getting T1 the services he needs will help you feel less guilty about the situation. Also, if you do find that you are feeling very stressed or having a difficult time with this I hope you do consider seeking counseling. There is no shame in needing a little extra support during a time like this. If you need a recommendation for a therapist in the Chicago area, I would be more like happy to give you a few (I’ve almost got my PhD in clinical psychology so know lots of them).
Reply
October 11th, 2011 on 7:36 pm
I’ve got the mommy guilt down pretty good. I spent the first 6 months of my son’s life drowning in because of a galactosemia mis-diagnosis, recalled formula, a hospitalization for failure to thrive, and a “failed” breastfeeding relationship. I bet myself up everyday over all of the things I didn’t have control over or things I couldn’t change. I still look back and feel such a sense of loss because I spent so much of my son’s babyhood sad and racked with guilt.
The one thing I’ve learned out of all of this is that the only thing you can do is love your child and use that love to move you forward. You can’t change that this is where he is at this point in time, but you can change where he might be tomorrow. I hope you can foster all your energy into getting him the help that he needs and deserves. Just the fact that you’re worried about this, the fact that you feel this way and even shared it with the world, shows that you care.
Reply
October 11th, 2011 on 8:05 pm
If you need the resources of the March of Dimes in Chicago, my friend is an audiologist there and might be able to help. I think they provide a variety of services.
My husband didn’t speak one iota until almost 2 and he is a neurosurgeon now. These days he can be found giving lots of presentations and winning awards for them, actually.
I love the comment above with the “digest, deal with it, do something”. I deal with this a lot when patients ask me why they have cancer or if they should have come in for evaluation sooner, etc.
I get the sense that in life guilt arises sometimes from things that are very close to the surface anyway ~ If, by looking through your retrospectoscope you feel that you could have talked to T1 more, or encouraged more interaction, read more books, or played more often… don’t dwell. You didn’t know what you didn’t know and it may not be relevant anyway. Just be proactive now, get the help you need to feel in control, and be grateful that with a life in flux comes those living it who are flexible.
Reply
October 11th, 2011 on 9:30 pm
Don’t feel bad! How on earth could it be your fault??? It’s not. However, I would not recommend waiting. It’s seems to me (who knows nothing) that most of the learning happens when babies/children are young. So while a three month delay in high school or college is no big deal, but it could make a bigger difference when it’s 1/6th of your age.
big hug.
Reply
October 12th, 2011 on 12:34 am
Hey, Jenna. You and TH are great parents. You arranging for therapies and that you noticed the delay itself shows that you care for T1.
Sometimes, a kid’s character comes into play in relation to their development. My sister never learnt to take steps. Neither did she babble. Once she felt ready though, she went from crawling straight up to taking 12 STEADY steps non-stop, and went from occasional sounds to simple complete sentences, bypassing babbling entirely.
She has always been very cautious and prefers to observe everything, and only does things once she has weighed all the options.
Me, on the other hand, crawled, bumbled steps, babbled incessantly, but took longer to get things right. I’ve always been the one to dive headlong and crash-course on things.
Again, please know that you are both doing the best for T1
Reply
October 12th, 2011 on 4:05 am
i think it’s great that you shared so much! cudos!
i read only a few comments and many said that “children develop differently” and all that. i know that this is right and i agree, but the therapists have a point as well, don’t they? after all they are the professionals, right?
but don’t feel guilty! it’s no ones fault when a child is delayed! esp. when it comes to speech! he just needs to work on that with lovin people supporting him as much as they can.
one other thing: i know that therapies can cost a lot, but maybe you could ask family memmbers to chip in? or friends? that’s what we did when we had to have therapy for our little one and our insurance didn’t cover it.
as far as i know postponing therapy can affect the development a lot. when we asked our family for support they’ve been great and i didn’t want to postpone anything, because i was afraid that it might get worse…
have a great day with your son and enjoy him
that’s the best you can do. for him and for you
good luck you three!
Reply
October 12th, 2011 on 8:37 am
I just wanted to pipe in to share my story about my daughter. Back when she was somewhere between 18 months and 24 months (I can’t remember exactly), I had her evaluated because her pediatrician was concerned that she wasn’t talking. They came to do their evaluation, and she just didn’t want to the things they wanted her to do, like stack blocks, etc.
Fast forward a couple months, and she was right on track verbally. She’s seven now and all she does is talk.
Your son may have some developmental delays, or maybe he’s just developing on his own schedule. But I’m sure whatever it is, you will be able to handle it.
Reply
October 12th, 2011 on 9:01 am
Jenna, this has to be hard, but I know you can get through it ~ am thinking there was a greater purpose to the talk you gave awhile back on getting through life’s trials.
I know anecdotes don’t mean much, but one of my best friends has a psychology degree and focused on childhood development. After graduation she spent several years working with young kids at a day care. She is so knowledgeable about what is best for kids at any given stage. And- her son has a speech delay. He is now almost 3 and the last time I saw him, he was still not talking very much. He’s been going to therapy though and she says it has been a huge help for them all ~ poor little guy gets so frustrated being unable to communicate, but therapy has given them some tools to help out.
So again, sometimes even when doing everything right, these things happen. It sounds like therapy will be doable with your budget, and while it may be hard work, I know you can do it! It seems like you have the right personality that wants to soak up as much knowledge as you can, so I am sure you will jump into this problem with all of your resources and will do great.
Reply
October 12th, 2011 on 9:54 am
Sending more hugs and good thoughts your way. I know it’s probably hard not to, but please don’t feel guilty about this. I know you will do everything you can to help out T1 and you are a great mom!!
Reply
October 12th, 2011 on 11:03 am
You have not done anything wrong, you did not “ruin” T1, and it makes me feel awful that you feel that way
You are an excellent mother and this too shall pass.
xoxo
Reply
October 12th, 2011 on 11:14 am
Jenna,
I do not know much about children with speech issues, but I was someone who had reading issues as a child. Specifically, that I was able to read large words but had difficulty with words such as, “and”, “the”, “is”, etc. Do I think my issue was because of my mother, heck no! Sometimes kids just have a difficult time. My mother was a truly loving, involved, wonderful mother who read to me all the time, but guess what I just had that difficulty as a child. So like I know you will do for T1 she sent me to a specialist. I became, my mother’s most avid reader out of her three children. Don’t feel guilty, it truly is not you and remember that no kid is perfect and some kids just need more help when they are little. The important thing it to take the steps you are taking now, which is getting him help and working with him. If you were the awful mother, these crappy people claim you are, then your child would not be as bright and wonderful as he is today. He is amazing, in all the other ways because of the great mom you are, this is just how he was going to be. But know that if you can tackle this issue now and work with him like you plan to do it should correct itself and who knows, you make have the next great orator of the United States as your son!
Reply
October 12th, 2011 on 5:08 pm
It’s totally normal to feel guilty, but you should know that it’s not your fault. A large number of children need speech-language intervention (around 20%), so you and T1 are not alone. You should give yourself credit for getting his hearing checked and getting him seen at a young age by a speech-language pathologist.
I’m an SLP working with kids 0-5 years of age. All the research shows that the earlier the intervention, the better the outcomes, so if you can proceed with therapy now, that would be the best for T1 according to the research. However, could you ask for a visit every 2 weeks to help save on cost? Ask the therapist to recommend activities for you and T1 to do in the meantime and ways to incorporate his language goals into your daily routines. The research also shows that parents and caregivers are the most important people to effect change in a child’s life, so it is more important that you be working on language on a daily basis than it is for a therapist to be coming in once per week.
Also, if you are looking for some nice resources for parents, check out http://www.hanen.org They have tips for parents, and I use the book “It Takes Two to Talk” all the time with parents. It has nice strategies for moms and dads on how to help their children develop language through everyday routines.
Good luck with everything. You love your son, and you’ll be great.
Reply
Jenna Reply:
October 12th, 2011 at 7:18 pm
Thanks so much for the great link Lacey!
Reply
October 12th, 2011 on 9:00 pm
My brother didn’t talk until he was 3. They all said he was ‘delayed’. He got his PhD from Columbia last month. Just sayin’.
Reply
October 13th, 2011 on 10:04 am
After reading all these comments, I have nothing to add about P and the good job you are doing as a Mom that someone else hasn’t already said.
But WOW, what an incredible community and support system you have that so many people are so willing and ready to stand by your side as you go through these trying times! The trolls may suck, but there sure are some awesome comments here from strangers.
You are so blessed.
You will get through this.
And I know in the end, you will end up not only helping your son, but so many other people as well. Good luck.
Reply
October 13th, 2011 on 11:19 am
I haven’t read all the comments…but I think it’s kinda funny that so many people are anti the “sing-songy” voice. Talking to babies in a higher-pitched voice is something found cross-culturally. Psychologists call it “motherese” and the theory is that babies have an easier time hearing at that pitch and so mothers instinctively do it. Going “goo-goo-ga-ga” at a kid or being super annoying isn’t going to help anyone, but there are evolutionary reasons that we talk to babies the way we do; it’s not just a modern overly concerned parenting invention.
Reply
Sophia Reply:
October 13th, 2011 at 6:12 pm
I’m glad you brought this up. We talked about this in one of my gender and family classes (although I still cringe at the term “motherese”, for whatever reason). For me personally, it’s not necessarily that I am “anti the sing songy voice” it’s that the sing songy voice is unfortunately usually accompanied by baby talk that annoys me to no end. It’s not usually the tone, it’s the content, but I find that most people who go all sing songy usually get off in the weeds when it comes to proper grammar/speaking nonsense. I have conversations with kids, and as a teacher of young English learners I know I adopted a higher pitched, expressive voice, wide eyes, etc. It’s the over done “does her wanna wittle boppy boo? Oh yes her does!!” thing that drives me batty. As you said, going “goo goo ga ga at a kid” definitely doesn’t help them learn to talk
Reply
October 13th, 2011 on 6:38 pm
I have to agree. I work at a community services board in the child & adolescent dept. we have an Infant & toddler program too…and a lot of the children who get services like speech when they are his age, do not need them by the time they’d qualify for our program (4 years old)….the earlier the better!
we have income based payment for people who do not have insurance or whose insurance does not cover it, so of they won’t work with you on payment, look up CSB or behavioral health in your area. Good luck! It may also enable him to receive free speech services at the public school if he needs it at 2-3 years old!
Reply