Dear fellow bloggers,
This topic gets me so riled up that I had to put the post title in all caps to properly convey my emotions.
If you have this turned on for your blog:
Give me one good reason why you have it.
Just one.
Is it that you don’t have to deal with spam? What if I told you that my bride blog on blogger gets an average of 200 visitors a day right now (at one point I was close to 500!), and I hardly dealt with any spam in all that time.
Have you been whining about comments lately? Have you stopped to think that maybe turning off word verification would encourage people to comment more often?
You say to me “Why don’t you care enough about me to leave a comment on my blog?”
And I say to you “Why don’t you care enough about your readers to make talking to you as easy as possible?”
I am thisclose to instituting a No Comment If Verification policy for myself.
If you don’t want to deal with going to your blog to delete spam, just enable the “approve all comments” option for Blogger. This means that you can filter out any spam messages before they ever go up on your blog. But your loyal readers don’t have to squint and strain their eyes to deciper a code like asodifj09239408 with a line drawn through it.
How about you turn it off for 1 month? Or 2? And then decide if you are being overwhelmed with messages about hot babes in bikinis.
I’m feeling snarky so I’m going to go ahead and say it: Odds are, your blog isn’t even popular enough for the spammers to care about.
Whew, was that rude? Are you all going to stop reading now? Because it’s likely true. None of my blogs have been popular enough to get attacked on a daily or weekly basis (well, I do get some spam on That Wife, but with WordPress I don’t have to deal with it). That Bride has 285 subscribers on Google Reader. Since April 18, 2008 That Bride has had 83,704 page views (according to Google Analytics, the number is 92,000 according to statcounter), and even with all of those pageviews, I’ve still only deleted a few spam comments. Statcounter tells me I’ve had 62,385 unique visitors at That Bride. Out of those 62,385 maybe 20 have spammed me. Maybe.
I’m not trying to brag. I’m just trying to use statistics to prove my point. I’ve heard that numbers can be very convincing.
So TURN IT OFF. TURN IT OFF. TURN IT OFF.
If you do, you might see me popping by to say hello a little more often!
Love ya!
That Wife
P.S.-If you are using blogger, and you are clueless about how to turn verification off, leave a comment and I’ll reply with step-by-step instructions on how to either turn word verification off, or turn the feature to approve all comments on.















March 5th, 2009 on 12:26 pm
Sorry, I’m keeping it. After being spammed several times (and having stupid people click on the links before I was able to delete them) I started moderating comments and I got a lot of complaints, so I switched to word verification. Besides you I’ve never had a complaint about word verification
.
Reply
March 5th, 2009 on 12:31 pm
wordpress has an awesome feature – it lets you turn on comment moderation once. ie if someone has left an approved comment on your blog one time you don’t have to approve again.
Reply
katealtmix Reply:
March 5th, 2009 at 7:35 pm
love this feature! we totally utilize it, works great!
Reply
March 5th, 2009 on 12:33 pm
Oh Jenna, I’m glad you posted this! I didn’t even know I had it on! Also, I had no open commenting allowed. Hopefully I get more comments now b/c they make me so happy! Maybe even one from you haha
Reply
March 5th, 2009 on 12:42 pm
I don’t mind those Captcha things too much – minor annoyance compare to people who have blogs you need to create an account or log in to comment for. That’s a major pet peeve – if it takes me more than 20 seconds to leave a comment, then you need to rethink your comment system.
Reply
March 5th, 2009 on 12:43 pm
I too, HATE the word verification. On my tiny laptop screen (11″), it really distorts the pixels, and I can wind up having to try 4 or 5 times before I get the word right.
When I actually post, I can get 300-400 hits in a day on my blog. I have actually had spam problems in the past, but as soon as I see the spam goes up (since I get all comments sent to my email), I just go in and delete it immediately. Sure, maybe people who get all replies emailed to them are mildly annoyed, but I figure they are far less annoyed than having to go through word verification each and every time they want to comment. Generally, spam comes in a giant bunch — they’ll spam to 10 or 15 posts in a row, so once they start, I’ll turn on the word verification for 10 minutes to shoo them away, and it does the trick, and then turn it back off again.
Until I am getting spammed on a regular per-post basis, I vow to NOT turn on word verification!
Reply
March 5th, 2009 on 12:45 pm
Oops… I thought I had turned it off on my blog. How annoying!
I completely agree with you that the verification is irritating. Especially because I am wrong about 75% of the time when I type the letters. Grrrr….
Reply
March 5th, 2009 on 12:53 pm
You have to be careful, blog spot is sneaky. If it’s your blog you don’t have to do the word verification even if it is turned on then you think it isn’t on. But it is! It’s maddening!
Sorry, got away from myself. Though it’s weird how spammers brains work. My blog is no where near as popular as yours but I’ve gotten a few random ones that I’ll just promptly delete meanwhile I’ve known others that get attacked constantly and are very small.
I have no idea how they pick them but it seems to have nothing to do with traffic and just random. I suppose I find word verification annoying but I can kinda understand why some people feel they need it over others.
Reply
March 5th, 2009 on 12:58 pm
it’s not necessarily about the amount of readers you get, it’s also about the content of your blog. i get at least 5 spam comments per day. insane. the bots search keywords + locations in search engines, not really page hits…
also, once you get one spam & miss it, it makes it easier for other spam bots to find & implant their evilness. that’s why even letting one spam comment go can be dangerous – the program will register that a spam comment was successful & tell the program to continue coming back & spamming (it works the same with email – once you open a spam email, many have codes in them that send a message back saying you opened it, which means your email is active, which means to SPAM MORE)
Reply
March 5th, 2009 on 1:07 pm
In case my blog was one of the offenders, I turned it off. I think it defaults that way and I never thought to turn it off!
Reply
March 5th, 2009 on 1:09 pm
Whoops! Never knew I had it on!
Reply
March 5th, 2009 on 1:20 pm
Great post! I had mine on too (cause it’s a default) and just removed it
Reply
March 5th, 2009 on 1:28 pm
yea, I never even thought about turning it off, but now i will, sorry!
wondering about your “still using blogger” comment and what you like about wordpress- i’m thinking of starting a jewelry blog separate from daily life stuff…
Reply
March 5th, 2009 on 1:28 pm
I removed mine a long long time ago (once I realized I had it), but last month I had a spam attack. More than 20 spams in one morning. So I turned it back on.
I do agree it’s anoying for readers, but less than spams.
You reminded me of it though. It could have been just an unusual spam occurrence… but who knows?
I’m going to follow Julie’s idea to only turn it on temporarily once you get spams… I’ll see. If I get attacked again I’ll switch to moderating comments.
Reply
March 5th, 2009 on 1:33 pm
Amen!
Reply
March 5th, 2009 on 1:43 pm
Well you already know how I feel about this! But I must add, to anyone who is reluctant to turn it off, citing the lack of complaints about it, you have no idea how many more readers might have commented if you’d made it easier for them. It really is a lot less hassle to delete just one spam comment than for one reader to complete the Word Verification Challenge.
Reply
March 5th, 2009 on 1:46 pm
Can we go one step further and request that everyone on blogger change their Comment Form Placement to Embedded below post? I’ll even give the directions…from the dashboard go to Settings>Comments>Comment Form Placement>Embedded below post (it’s the last option).
It really iritates me to have to wait for additional windows to pop-up/load in order to leave a comment. When I’m reading posts on my phone (which I do often), it’s even more annoying b/c I can’t easily switch from one page to another. UGH!
There, it feels so good to get that off my chest. Thanks for the soapbox!
Reply
Janssen Reply:
March 5th, 2009 at 3:08 pm
The thing I don’t like about the embedded comment form is that you have to scroll past every single comment to get to it. Unless you only have a very small amount of comments, I find this very annoying. I’d rather have it load a new full-page.
Reply
JaymeLyn Reply:
March 5th, 2009 at 3:29 pm
I didn’t realize it was an option, but i really dislike the full page feature on blogspot. The little pop out window doesn’t bother me as much, but I like the embedded form better.
Reply
kaitlyn Reply:
March 5th, 2009 at 4:59 pm
Another reason to turn off the verification– it often messes up on the embedded comment box.
Reply
rksquared Reply:
March 6th, 2009 at 12:26 am
I think the embedded option is fairly new (showed up this winter). I changed mine after seeing it on another blogger site, and I believe it is the default option for new blogs now.
Reply
Cate Subrosa Reply:
March 6th, 2009 at 3:38 am
I have never been able to comment on a blog using the embedded comment box, and this has stopped me commenting on many blogs, including, sadly, yours! I don’t know why it doesn’t work, but when I hit post comment, nothing happens. I am using a mac and it won’t work with Firefox or Safari
Reply
rksquared Reply:
March 6th, 2009 at 11:26 am
I’m so sad that you aren’t able to comment on my blog! My computer has some strange glitches like that as well. For instance I don’t see the “quick edit” or “delete comment” icons when viewing my blog on my computer (IE or Firefox), but I can see them when I’m on my husband’s computer. On another site I visited recently there were entire sections of the pages that didn’t show up on my computer, but my husband could see them from his work computer. I just assume I have a virus or something that causes that.
Feel free to send me an email anytime you want to comment!
Reply
Jenna Reply:
March 10th, 2009 at 11:02 am
I have issues commenting on your blog a lot as well. I just copy my comment and refresh the page and try again, but it’s still kind of annoying.
Reply
March 5th, 2009 on 2:09 pm
way to say it Jenna! Hopefully no one is offended. Its so true, I give up so frequently when i try to make comments on some blogs that i just stop trying. I type it all out, and then I have to figure out if that little scribble is an ‘rn’ or an ‘m’ and I just say, oh who cares and close the window. And I think it’s true, most people dont even know they have it on
Reply
March 5th, 2009 on 2:39 pm
I’m going to remove it, because your points are good.
But even my stupid little NO VISISTORS EVER blogs have both been spammed like nobody’s business… So, you’d be surprised.
Reply
March 5th, 2009 on 2:51 pm
Guess what? I think I turned mine off…did not even know it was on.
That is how much i know about blogger.
Thanks for this post
Reply
March 5th, 2009 on 3:05 pm
I’ve turned mine off for now, but I turned it off about a year ago, when I had much lower traffic, and I got several spam comments the first day.
I’ll give it a week, but if I’m getting a lot of spam, it’s going right back on. Since most Blogger or Typepad blogs have one, I think many many people are just used to doing it.
Reply
March 5th, 2009 on 3:10 pm
(salutes) Yes Ma’am!
I actually didn’t know it was on and have a feeling that nothing will change with it off. In the past year, I’ve only had one random, weird comment from someone I didn’t know, so unless it becomes a problem, it will stay off. I also changed my setting so that I’m not able to be found with searh engines, etc, though I’m still publicly available (I admit that I hate it when people I know go private – I’m lazy! I hate that extra step!)
Reply
March 5th, 2009 on 3:15 pm
Mine was already off – I changed it before when someone brought it up, but thanks to rksquared I’ve also changed the format option (to be honest I didn’t know that that *meant*!)
Would you believe the first two comments I ever got on my blog were spam? And I think they were “real person” spam, rather than automated spambots, because they commented on my blog specifically – “why don’t you write something interesting instead of this boring rubbish?” was the gist of one, but before my feelings were too hurt I held my mouse over the commenter’s name and discovered it took me to a site for the national lottery. Obviously they thought by leaving hurtful comments I would click to find out who they were, and hey, maybe enter the lotto while I was there! Moron. So that’s when I turned on comment moderation.
Reply
March 5th, 2009 on 3:21 pm
After you left a lovely comment on my blog … I am taking the “leap of faith” and I just turned off both the verification piece, and the “have to have an ID” function.
Today has been strangely huge on my site, so it will be an excellent test to see if people are prone to leaving spam.
I’m leaving on “moderation for comments over 14 days old” because that seems to be where I get spam. People do a quick search and then want to leave advertising on my posts. No thanks!
Thanks for the suggestion, Jenna
Reply
March 5th, 2009 on 3:25 pm
good post! i didn’t even know I had mine on. i feel sorry for my one commenter now
Reply
March 5th, 2009 on 3:26 pm
I think people that still have it probably don’t really realize what a PITA it is and have it based on default. Which means you maybe coulda been a teeny-tiny bit less snarky about the whole thing…not that I mind snark, but it really is sooooo unlike you!
Reply
March 5th, 2009 on 3:35 pm
I don’t think xanga even has an option for turning the word verification function off. But imho, I don’t think it’s a big deal. When I leave comments on non-xanga blogs, I have to type out my name, email, and website anyway. What’s a few more letters and seconds?
Reply
March 5th, 2009 on 3:44 pm
I guess I agree with everyone else here – many people don’t even know it’s on because we rarely comment on our own blogs. I’ve gone back and forth between turning it on and off – and I still get a small amount of spam either way.
Reply
March 5th, 2009 on 3:44 pm
Hello, it is a hassle specialy when you are reading from your phone and the letters are tiny!
But how do I turn it off? I’m not even sure if mine is off or on?
Reply
March 5th, 2009 on 3:48 pm
Haha it drives me nuts too! I’m glad WordPress doesn’t use it.
Reply
March 5th, 2009 on 3:49 pm
I didn’t know mine was on! I’m so glad you wrote this post so I could know to check. Not that I have more than like 3 readers… but I love comments (who doesn’t) and would never want to make commenting less fun!
Bravo on “TURN IT OFF!”
Reply
March 5th, 2009 on 4:05 pm
Dear Jenna,
I have it on. I’m keeping it on due to spam. I have less readers than you. My blog is not popular. But spam likes it…
SORRY.
Amanda
Reply
March 5th, 2009 on 4:06 pm
I turned my off sometime last year. I’ve gotten some spam but not enough for me to be upset about it. It’s usually funny.
Reply
March 5th, 2009 on 4:08 pm
ohk. i’ll turn it off. I just realized I could approve all comments. it’s late. sorry for being cheeky. couldn’t help myself.
Reply
March 5th, 2009 on 4:11 pm
Lol, I love how many people didn’t know they had it on and you saved them!
Reply
March 5th, 2009 on 4:58 pm
Had zero clue that mine has been on this whole time. Another commenter mentioned it – blogger tricks you into thinking it’s off because when I comment on my own posts, it doesn’t require the word verification. I’ll give it a whirl…see if removing it increases my comments! Haha!
Reply
March 5th, 2009 on 5:00 pm
I had mine on when I first started blogging (it’s the default), and turned it off when I realized “Hey, my blog really ISN’T popular enough to be spammed”. So great post!
Reply
March 5th, 2009 on 5:02 pm
Jen – I HATE the word verification thing, but I don’t know how to turn it off…teach me.
Reply
Jenna Reply:
March 10th, 2009 at 11:07 am
Dashboard–>Settings
Scroll down until you see “show word verification for comments”,and choose no.
If you start to get spammed, just change the setting for “comment moderation” to “always” and then you will just have to approve comments before they go up.
Reply
March 5th, 2009 on 5:03 pm
Amen! I’m truly with you on this one. It makes me crazy. And some are harder than others to decipher.
Reply
March 5th, 2009 on 5:03 pm
Amen sister! I hate word verification with a passion!
Reply
March 5th, 2009 on 5:27 pm
I find it kinda annoying too
Especially when my screen doesn’t refresh properly and my comment is lost. This has happened a couple of times and I usually forget about retyping my comment out again
Reply
March 5th, 2009 on 5:27 pm
okie those smilie faces were supposed to be smilies with their tongues sticking out
Reply
March 5th, 2009 on 6:29 pm
Jenna, I also have it on BECAUSE (while I have never had spam), my sister in law who has a not-so-popular blog had a huge problem with spam before she turned the word verification on. I’d rather not have to sort through everything on top of everything else I have to do! But personally I don’t think that it is annoying at all.
Reply
March 5th, 2009 on 6:38 pm
Personally, the word verification thing is growing on me… especially when it almost spells words. Like one time I had to write the word gombelse, I laughed outloud when I wrote it.
But I too have my pet peeves: Like when people say eXpecially, even after you’ve politely corrected them. Ooooo just typing it makes me shudder. THERE IS NO X or even an X SOUND in the word especially.
Reply
March 5th, 2009 on 8:28 pm
As one without a blog who enjoys reading, and occasionally commenting on, other people’s blogs, I don’t find word verification annoying at all.
I do get realllllllllllly tired of logging in to read friends’ blogs though. I read the ones that require a password less often, because it never recognizes my phone and I can’t be bothered retyping everything in again each time.
And I hear ya Taylor on the expecially. What about “liberry” instead of libRARY? WHY do people turn an educational institution into a fruit?! WHY?!
Reply
March 5th, 2009 on 11:32 pm
this is only one on a long list of things i hate re: blogs!
Reply
March 6th, 2009 on 10:25 am
I don’t think it goes by blog popularity for spam, mine got hit a couple of times, but I found once I turned it on for a couple of months when I turned it off it hasn’t started again. I agree it is annoying.
Reply
March 6th, 2009 on 10:38 am
is it really that big of a deal to type 6 letters? i’ve never had a problem.
…and i don’t really care if people comment on my blogs or not. i post because i enjoy it. if people want to comment, great. if not, who cares?
and if someone isn’t going to post on my blog because i have word verification, i suppose they’re not really that interested in my life if the have 3 extra seconds it takes to type a few letters is too much of a burden…
Reply
March 6th, 2009 on 11:21 am
that’s what i was thinking, kacey. i was like, “jesus – think about how much time i spend updating, designing, and maintain my blog – and they can’t take 9 seconds to type in some letters?”
makes me wonder if they’re commenting to actually comment, or commenting to get readers to their *own* sites?
it’s worth the effort to me. *shrugs*
Reply
March 6th, 2009 on 2:44 pm
I hate it too!!! Glad you posted this. I use wordpress and thankfully my spam is collected for me, so I’ve never had to do any sort of word verification. I do get alot of spammers… 10-20 weekly, but luckily it is caught by wordpress. Which is just one of the small reason I love WP way more than blogger.
Reply
March 6th, 2009 on 3:20 pm
hmh…what you write makes me wonder. I don’t agree it’s THAT annoying, it takes really 1 seconds to type in and does not involve new windows popping up or having to concentrate on a difficult to follow instruction…or (to me) anything annoying at all.
but I do get few comments, so I’m willing to do a trial for a month. the number of comments is low, although they are usually from loyal readers, so I don’t see that as a negative. these return ‘commentators’ give me a sense of having a discussion; rather than having (often) contentless oneliners from 5 people….
On the other hand stats say the blog’s audience grows progressively (and independently of whether I blog frequently or leave for 2 months) so it does make me wonder why the growth of traffic is not proportional to growth of comments – ? and here you have my attention:)
I’m doubtful removing word verification will increase comments. I think the loyal ‘commentators’ will continue to comment with a similar frequency. But I am willing to take the dare see if people will feel more incentivised… I’ll let you know in a month I guess:)
Reply
March 6th, 2009 on 8:53 pm
I had no idea that was even happening on my blog – thanks for the head’s up!
Reply
March 7th, 2009 on 12:46 pm
Yep, I have to keep it myself. I didn’t have it on for my first few months, and I got spammed a LOT. and not just one spam message here or there either — dozens on new and old posts. Nasty, obscene ones about pills that enhance certain male body parts, etc. I suppose comment approval is a thought though. I thought it was good that I at least allow non-blogger people to comment – I hate it when people force you to log in to blogger just to make a comment.
Reply